Sahra Wagenknecht & Alternative for Germany:
The German Right’s Dilemma
Clarissa Schnabel
1,435 words
It is amusing in a depressing sort of way to watch the current about-turn of the German political Right regarding Sahra Wagenknecht. Wagenknecht was a well-known politician of Die Linke, the Leftist uniparty — kind of post-reunification Germany’s version of the Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED). But in recent years she made herself rather unpopular with her comrades, to the point of being threatened with being kicked out of her own party. In 2021 Wagenknecht published a book titled Die Selbstgerechten (The Self-Righteous Ones), her criticism of the modern Left’s betrayal of its former ideals.
The mainstream press, clearly confused by its own bias, called Wagenknecht an “enigma.” Why? Because Sahra Wagenknecht said many things that the evil right-wing Alternative for Germany (AfD) was also saying. Of course, nobody stopped to think that both Wagenknecht and the AfD simply took a position that would have been squarely in the centrist camp not so many years ago. You know, common sense stuff such as that maybe unrestricted immigration is not such a good idea, or green policy is impoverishing the working and middle classes as well as destroying Germany’s industry, or getting involved in America’s endless wars for no good reason is perhaps not in the nation’s best interest. (It should be noted that both the AfD and Wagenknecht are very pro-Russian, even if only because they are tired of the United States calling the shots in Germany. But that is a whole other topic.) So of course Sahra Wagenknecht became suspect to everyone from the far Left to the so-called conservatives. She also became a heroine for many on the Right, to the point of speculation that she might join the AfD.
Personally, I respect Wagenknecht. She has sound political ideas, she is able to express herself convincingly and reasonably, and she is the one Leftist politician whom I would actually vote for. (Well, no — there is also Boris Palmer of the Green party.) But apparently, I paid better attention than others to what she was saying, because she made it very clear over the years that she had no love for the Right.
For quite a while now, rumors have circulated that Wagenknecht planned to found her own party, plans that were hailed by her fans on the Right. Now we know it’s actually going to happen. “Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht” (Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance) is the name chosen for Germany’s newest party, and I’m still undecided whether it’s a good public relations move or sheer egocentrism. With that name, will the party even have a life beyond Wagenknecht?
If, however, AfD politicians had imagined the perfect coalition partner in Wagenknecht’s party, they were quickly robbed of that delusion. Almost the first thing Sahra Wagenknecht did was to declare her intention of luring voters away from the AfD, and her willingness to cooperate with both Die Linke and the conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU, which is Angela Merkel’s party).
Immediately, the imaginary love affair turned sour. Having lauded Wagenknecht only weeks ago, AfD politicians and voters now attack her in the most ridiculous ways. I can’t help but think that they only have themselves to blame. Wagenknecht was always very consistent in her renunciation of the Right. People simply refused to listen.
How will Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht influence the next election? I can only speculate, of course. First of all, I’m not sure how many representatives Wagenknecht’s party can actually muster. Will there be enough for party chapters on a local level?
Aside from that, however, yes, I do believe she will attract many of those potential voters who have swelled the ranks of the AfD in recent polls. They switched to the AfD because it was the only party people with any common sense could still vote for. But now that Wagenknecht promises basically the same policies without the stigma of being an “extremist” or “Nazi,” people will choose the more moderate option. (Being a former Communist somehow doesn’t count as extremist.) There will, of course, be some converts from Die Linke who, like Wagenknecht herself, are dissatisfied with modern Leftist politics, and I suspect quite a number of people who continued to vote for the established mainstream parties just because they couldn’t possibly vote for an “evil” party, as a colleague of mine once put it, will at least give Wagenknecht a try. Polls show Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht at a potential 14% already.
The statistics are certainly interesting, though it should be considered that the poll was commissioned by ARD, a state-sponsored news outlet. It shows that AfD voters are most likely to switch to Wagenknecht’s party (55%), while voters of the Green party are least likely to do so (13%).
From the declaration of the party’s founders on why they have left Die Linke (my translation and commentary):
The conflicts of recent years have been about the political course of DIE LINKE. [Yes, they write its name in all caps. Talk about being pushy.] Time and again, we have argued that the wrong priorities and the lack of focus on social justice and peace are diluting the party’s profile. We have repeatedly warned that the focus on urban, young, activist milieus is driving away our traditional voters. Time and again, we have tried to halt the party’s decline by changing its political course. We were unsuccessful — and as a result, the party was less and less successful with voters. The history of DIE LINKE since the 2019 European elections is the history of political failure. The respective party leaderships and the officials supporting them at the state level were determined not to discuss this failure critically under any circumstances. No responsibility was taken for it, nor did any substantive consequences follow from it. Instead, those who were critical of the party leadership’s course were identified as the culprits for the results and increasingly marginalized.
Against this backdrop, we no longer see a place for our positions in the party. One example is the “Aufstand für den Frieden” [“Uprising for Peace”] in February 2023. It was the largest peace rally in almost 20 years. Tens of thousands gathered in front of the Brandenburg Gate. Although — and precisely because — around half of the population rejects the government’s military course, the country’s entire political establishment opposed the rally and defamed it. Instead of supporting us in this dispute, the leadership of DIE LINKE stood shoulder to shoulder with the other parties: It accused the rally’s organizers of being “open to the Right,” and thus provided the cue for accusations against us. . . .
What drives us: We no longer want to accept this political development. The socially devastating policy of the Ampel [literally “traffic light”, the current ruling coalition, so called because of the parties’ colors: red (SPD), yellow (FDP) and green (Die Grünen)] is costing large sections of the population their income and quality of life. German foreign policy is fueling wars instead of trying to find peaceful solutions. International conflicts are escalating; the emerging bloc is a threat to world peace and will cause massive economic upheaval. At the same time, opposition to this political development is increasingly sanctioned and pilloried in public debate. But democracy needs diversity of opinion and open debate. The government’s inability to deal with the crises of our time and the narrowing of the accepted corridor of opinion have pushed the AfD to the top. Many people simply no longer know how else to articulate their protest. In this situation, DIE LINKE no longer presents itself as a clearly recognizable opposition, but as a soft-spoken “Yes, but . . .” party. By taking this course it has sunk below the population’s perception threshold. At present, everything indicates that it will no longer be represented in the next Bundestag, while the AfD is polling at over 20%.
Frankly, the AfD won’t have a chance at implementing its politics, at least not without holding the absolute majority. Even 23%, according to some polls, would not be enough. No party in Germany, at least on the federal and probably state levels, would ever cooperate with the AfD. It would be blocked at every turn; this is simply the sad reality of things.
My hope now is that AfD politicians will get over their childish huff as quickly as possible. Sahra Wagenknecht might not be willing to work with them, but that is no reason why they should not work with her; again, their main political points are similar enough. If, by supporting Wagenknecht’s proposals, the AfD can get what it wants anyway, where is the problem? It’s called Realpolitik. Hurt feelings have no place in it.
Sahra%20Wagenknecht%20andamp%3B%20Alternative%20for%20Germany%3A%0AThe%20German%20Rightand%238217%3Bs%20Dilemma%0A
Share
Enjoyed this article?
Be the first to leave a tip in the jar!
* * *
Counter-Currents has extended special privileges to those who donate at least $10/month or $120/year.
- Donors will have immediate access to all Counter-Currents posts. Everyone else will find that one post a day, five posts a week will be behind a “paywall” and will be available to the general public after 30 days. Naturally, we do not grant permission to other websites to repost paywall content before 30 days have passed.
- Paywall member comments will appear immediately instead of waiting in a moderation queue. (People who abuse this privilege will lose it.)
- Paywall members have the option of editing their comments.
- Paywall members get an Badge badge on their comments.
- Paywall members can “like” comments.
- Paywall members can “commission” a yearly article from Counter-Currents. Just send a question that you’d like to have discussed to [email protected]. (Obviously, the topics must be suitable to Counter-Currents and its broader project, as well as the interests and expertise of our writers.)
To get full access to all content behind the paywall, please visit our redesigned Paywall page.
Related
-
What You Need to Know about the German New Right: An Interview with Martin Lichtmesz
-
The Worst Week Yet: March 10-16, 2024
-
Caught in a Time Loop: The Eternal Return of Leftist Hysteria
-
Remigration: Alternative for Germany and a Path Toward a Self-Confident Germany Once Again
-
Sometimes the Ship Has to Sink for the Rats to Desert
-
Hitler the Peacemaker: David L. Hoggan’s The Forced War, Part 5
-
Hitler the Peacemaker: David L. Hoggan’s The Forced War, Part 4
-
Hitler the Peacemaker: David L. Hoggan’s The Forced War, Part 3
11 comments
The ruling class in Germany, like that in Britain, are 100% subservient to (((American))) interests, but the people of Germany are not. It’s good to learn that the AfD are pro-Russian. A victory for Russia (and China) would be a defeat for the US Evil Empire, and hence a defeat for the Jews.
As for Sahra Wagenknecht and her followers, I don’t trust them one bit. Her party is just another scam. If they were honest, they would admit their errors, condemn DIE LINKE as willing tools of the Jews, endorse the AfD, and then withdraw from active politics. That would be constructive, so they won’t do that. They’re communists and professional “activists”. There’s no dealing with them. Their lack of humility proves their insincerity. They just want to wreck the chances of the AfD. That is their assigned task. They don’t care for Germany. Wagenknecht and her comrades are regular leftists, with the usual suicidal death wish.
I don’t have in-depth knowledge of German politics but I agree, she does seem to fit the profile of a communist who sets up a controlled opposition ‘trust’ which migrates to the right in order to garner votes and hamstring the real opposition. (((Frank Furedi))) and Brendan O’Neill who are often in the Spectator or on conservative podcasts have their Spiked! outfit. Are they trying to tell us something with the name. It’s no real secret that both were part of a group calling itself The Revolutionary Communist Party. Spiked holds the line against the trannies but third wave feminism and racial equality are givens. Presto, you have commies running a branch of Conservatism Inc. In the last month every second article is a polemic contra anti-semitism.
Wagenknecht is young and attractive so she’s well set for a cult following which may not notice her subtle policy shifts once elected. Once AfD has been hobbled some reason can be found for a more gradual destruction of the German Volk. Sie ist aber wirklich huebsch.
It is so strange to read when somebody wishes Red China and its Russian proxy to “win”, only to “defeat Evil US empire and Jews”. The victory of Red China would be BAD for any native European and Euroasian people, white or not white. The life of Uyghurs and Qazaqs and Tibetians under Chinese maoist rule confirms this. The principle of “my enemy’s enemy is my friend” does not work here. This is really the case when the medicine is worse than an illness.
So what are her policies on the migrants? My worry is that people, even in the AfD, will be so afraid of being thought mean that they will allow their country to be invaded, impoverished, and, if they continue down that road, conquered.
It’s not enough to reduce net migration. It’s not enough to stop it completely. They must be expelled or coerced to leave! Otherwise, Germany’s fate is sealed, due to differential birth rates and other reasons. Is anyone in Germany willing to do that? Nobody in America with a chance of being elected is, sadly…
A good point. I very much doubt that she would want to stop immigration altogether, which is the declared goal of the AfD. However, at this point, I take a reduction in immigration over a hope at zero percent immigration which will never come to pass under the current conditions. That is the problem I mentioned: The AfD might want to stop immigration, and they might try to implement it, but all the other parties will simply outvote them over this – just because they don’t want to be seen working with the AfD. It’s all so stupid.
Until politicians finally grow a backbone, not just Germany but all of Europe will be lost. That’s the other insanity here: I am pretty sure most politicians in the EU would be secretly glad if more countries were to finally say “Enough!” Sure, they would go through the motions of protesting and whatnot, but they’d be relieved. It’s just that they are all too afraid of each other’s opinion for anyone to go first.
So what are her policies on the migrants?
Well. her father was a migrant. From Iran. By the way, Sahra is a Muslim name, if you did not know.
Also, if her policies are similar to AfD’s, on what basis does she distinguish herself from them, given her dislike of them?
Simple: She’s not an evil right-winger.
Seriously though, I’m sure there are a few things on which both sides differ. But the fact that so many AfD voters sympathize with what she is saying, and that by her own statement her politcs are meant to draw voters away from the AfD, clearly shows that they agree on more things than they disagree on. At least for now; exactly how Wagenknecht’s ideas will evolve remains to be seen.
In my opinion, there is a real shortage of “pro-Russian” people in Germany and far too many pro-American people. I still remember when Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev let Germany re-unify and let the Warsaw Pact Alliance break up. There was great optimism about peace without nuclear weapons facing each other and Russia and Germany working together to advance the interests of Russia and Europe. Later, Chancellor Schroder helped arrange building the Nordstream Pipelines to bring cheap natural gas from Russia to Germany. With great optimism, the EURO was created. Rules were set in place so it would be based on the German Deutschmark, a hard currency that surged in value against the dollar in the 1970s.
My German parents were of the war generation, so neither had any love for Russians, but I think anyone with half a brain would recognize that Gorbachev had done the Germans a huge favor. Great Britain and the USA were also enemies of Germany in World War II. Since then, the euro has been devalued with policies contrary to those set forth at its creation. Germany’s “ally,” the US, recently blew up the multi-billion-dollar gas pipeline that was to bring cheap gas from Russia to Germany, and Europe has ceded control of its foreign policy to the Judeo-Bolsheviks that surround the senile Biden. They made the war in Ukraine happen, not in the interests of Ukrainians, which Jews and Americans call “NAZIS”, but to make Ukraine another western-style (Jewish-style) state with gay pride parades and holohoax indoctrination in the classrooms. Ukraine has been depopulated by over ten million people, and the war is lost. The US now wants the Ukrainians to sit down and negotiate. Good riddance.
Chancellor Scholz and Annalena Baerbock are criminal traitors who have continued the destruction that Merkel brought to Germany. It’s very disappointing to read this article. I thought there was a chance the AFD could get in power and stop the steep decline of Germany.
Gorbachev achieved the unification of Germany despite the terrible resistance of Great Britain (not of the USA!). Great Britain did not forgive him for this. In 1991 he was removed from power. He was lucky to stay alive, even as private person.
It must be remembered that from the beginning of the nineteenth century Russia was the main supplier of cannon fodder for the British Empire. The British fought with Russian hands against the French in the Napoleonic Wars, and against the Germans in the Anglo-German War of 1914-1945. Any attempts by the Russians to break out of this crypto-colonial dependence were suppressed with the help of political assassinations and terror. So, with the assistance of British intelligence services, Tsar Pavel I, who did not want to fight with France, and Grigory Rasputin, who wanted to stop Russia’s completely unnecessary participation in the so-called First World War, were killed. Thus, much later Marshal Tukhachevsky, who in the 1930s wanted rapprochement with Germany, and Lavrentiy Beria, who in 1953 advocated a neutral, united Germany free from occupation forces (modeled on the Austria’s neutrality of 1955), were removed from power and executed.
Great interview with AfD’s Maxmillian Krah on the not always so great Duran. He shows rare candor about racial, geopolitical, and demographic facts =
https://odysee.com/@theduran:e/germany-economic-decline-alternative:9
Comments are closed.
If you have Paywall access,
simply login first to see your comment auto-approved.
Note on comments privacy & moderation
Your email is never published nor shared.
Comments are moderated. If you don't see your comment, please be patient. If approved, it will appear here soon. Do not post your comment a second time.
Paywall Access
Lost your password?Edit your comment