Counter-Currents
  • Private Events
  • T&C
  • Rss
  • DLive
  • Telegram
  • Gab
  • Entropy
  • Rss
  • DLive
  • Telegram
  • Gab
  • Entropy
  • Webzine
  • Books
  • Podcasts
  • Donate
  • Paywall
  • Crypto
  • Mailing List
  • About
  • Contact
  • RSS
    • Main feed
    • Comments feed
    • Podcast feed

LEVEL2

  • Webzine
  • Books
  • Podcasts
  • Donate
  • Paywall
  • Crypto
  • Mailing List
  • About
  • Contact
  • RSS
    • Main feed
    • Comments feed
    • Podcast feed
  • Private Events
  • T&C
  • Rss
  • DLive
  • Telegram
  • Gab
  • Entropy
Print June 30, 2016 4 comments

A New Approach to Shakespeare Authorship

Christopher Pankhurst

1,075 words

Forty-Cover-WrapSamuel Crowell
William Fortyhands: Disintegration and Reinvention of the Shakespeare Canon
Charleston, W.V.: Nine-Banded Books, 2016

The idea that the plays of William Shakespeare were written by someone other than William Shakespeare is a well-established motif in literary conspiracy theories. Starting in the mid-19th century, numerous and varied writers have gone into great detail to prove that the Shakespeare corpus was actually written by Francis Bacon, Christopher Marlowe, or Edward de Vere, amongst others. These theories are entertaining enough, partly because they convey that gratifying feeling of having discovered hidden knowledge, and partly because they shine light into the puzzling lacunae of Shakespeare’s biography. But they have never been particularly convincing.

This leaves us with a situation where the known facts of Shakespeare’s life seem too paltry to tell us much about the writing of the plays, but the alternative candidates seem no more plausible. Consequently, we find a majority of scholars coalescing around the conventional attribution of the plays to Shakespeare (the Stratfordians) and smaller groups advocating for one or other of the alternative candidates (the anti-Stratfordians). In the absence of any greatly compelling evidence, positions on all sides tend to become rather fixed.

In his new book, William Fortyhands, Samuel Crowell gives an erudite and entertaining history of the background to the Shakespeare controversy, weighs the merits of all sides, and offers his own, surprisingly plausible solution.

Crowell characterises the literary milieu in which the plays were produced as the “Elizabethan Beats.” This description applies to the group of dissolute young men who congregated on the London theatrical world in the late 16th century, men like Christopher Marlowe. Like their 20th-century counterparts, these young writers embodied a “live fast, die young” ethos, and unlike the later beats mostly did die young. There were hundreds of plays being produced in England at this time and the Elizabethan Beats seem to have been an important engine of this industry. It is within this milieu that William Shakespeare left his legacy.

Famously, following Shakespeare’s death a folio of plays bearing his name was published. This has forever been the foundational document of Shakespeare studies but the situation is complicated because many of the plays had also appeared in quarto editions which were usually much shorter than the folio versions. Some of these quartos bore the name of Shakespeare but others were published anonymously. Even more confusingly, some of the individual plays were published in differing versions as quartos. Just to complete the confusion, earlier versions of the “Shakespeare” plays seem to have existed, written by other authors and upon which the Shakespeare versions seem to have been based, such as the Ur-Hamlet.

Crowell marshals all of this material expertly and gives an excellent and lucid account of the rise of Shakespeare studies culminating in David Garrick’s 1769 Jubilee festival in Stratford. Ironically, the increase in Shakespeare’s popularity and growing interest in his life led to the uncovering of certain documents (most notoriously his will) that began to provoke questions about authorship. Crowell documents the history of the authorship question in great detail and is careful to contextualize his study with various theoretical perspectives, too much so in my opinion. But this does at least demonstrate his good faith in seeking to approach an objective view rather than promoting a personal hobby horse.

Ultimately, Crowell concludes that the plays were probably written by a number of those Elizabethan Beats, either singly or collaboratively, and that a final position on who wrote exactly what is probably unknowable. The reason that Shakespeare’s name was so definitively associated with so many of the plays, Crowell argues, is that his role was something like editor and theatrical producer. Essentially, he sourced texts, edited them down for performance (the shorter quartos) and funded the whole enterprise. He would have been “informally presented” (p. 214) as the writer of the plays. Unlike the actual writers, Shakespeare appears to have been very wealthy at a time when playwrights were treated as cheap hacks.

This is an elegant interpretation of the available evidence. Even though it leaves us with a situation vastly more complex than attribution to any one single author, it allows us to go beyond all of the evidential problems that such attributions caused. It is an excellent application of Occam’s Razor because Crowell follows the evidence and accepts what it tells him, even if doing so seems to shatter our idea of what it means to be an author. It would appear that in the 18th century the person who actually wrote the words of the plays was not much of a consideration. The “pull” would have been the name of the producer who would have been associated with a string of hits. It doesn’t take too much imagination to see the sort of contemporary parallels with this. For example, films are generally more closely identified with their directors than their screenwriters. Perhaps an even better example would be the mythical creator of Bitcoin, Satoshi Nakamoto. It is quite possible that Satoshi is a pseudonym hiding a number of cryptocurrency experts. Perhaps we should start calling him Satoshi Fortyhands?

Despite Crowell’s compelling assessment of the evidence there are still questions remaining. Crowell points out that if Shakespeare really did write the plays then he must have amassed a great deal of knowledge from somewhere. It is pretty much agreed by everyone that he didn’t have an extensive education so perhaps he picked his knowledge up by socializing with a range of interesting and knowledgeable people?

If Shakespeare really was the sort of person who went to local drinking establishments to get the lowdown on legal terminology, Italian geography, hawking, or what have you, then one would expect more contemporary references to him as a real person. This is not what we find. Almost all the references to him are based strictly on the title page attributions of the plays and poems. (p. 236)

But if this mitigates against Shakespeare as a writer, which is primarily a solitary occupation, then surely it mitigates even more against Shakespeare as impresario, with all the organizational and publicity work that that would imply.

Such questions are unlikely to resolve into definitive answers, and Crowell is surely right to conclude that we will never come to a definitive conclusion about who wrote Shakespeare’s plays. The scenario he paints in William Fortyhands is remarkable for being at once a sober handling of the evidence and a radical reassessment of the authorship question.

 

Related

  • Male Supremacism in the United States?

  • Work to Be Such a Man

  • Put Many Tools into the Toolbox

  • Paul Fussell’s Class 40 Years On

  • Winter Wheat:
    American Blut und Boden

  • Léon Bloy & the Symbolism of History

  • The Birth of Post-War American Conservatism in Detroit

  • Shawn Bell’s Post—:
    A Review

Tags

book reviewsChristopher PankhurstWilliam Shakespeare

Previous

« The Left is Afraid

Next

» A Hero Despite Himself:
Bringing Mike Hammer to the Screen

4 comments

  1. Peter Quint says:
    June 30, 2016 at 9:20 am

    If you want to know who Shakespeare was, read Joseph Atwell’s “Shakespeare’ Secret Messiah.” It was Amelia Bassano.

    1. Anonymous says:
      July 1, 2016 at 6:08 pm

      I haven’t read that one yet, but found Caesar’s Messiah compelling evidence that the NT was written at the Flavian court. Interesting alternative to “Christianity as Jewish psy-op” theory.

      1. Interested Observer says:
        July 4, 2016 at 9:39 pm

        Atwell’s “Caesar’s Messiah” was good. Robert Eisenmann’s “James the Brother of Jesus” is a much more comprehensive and scholarly study of the time period that points to the same conclusions.

        Essentially, you had the cult of the deified Caesar, starting with Julius (betrayed by Judas Brutus.) It was the Flavians, Vespasian, the Father, Jesus Titus, the Son, and his brother Domitian (the Awful Spirit), that merged their cult with Judaism during the Roman-Jewish war, going so far as to marry into a Jewish royal house. The “pagans” then suppressed that aspect of the cult until their descendant, Constantine, established it officially a few hundred years later.

        The writings of Josephus and other contemporary writers provide some important context as well. It’s all been there, pretty openly, forever.

        Counter Current’s own James J. O’Meara has written about how the Romans did essentially the same thing to the Germans – they took the German pagan religion and inserted their own cult into it and wrote a “New Testament” with Jesus character as a pagan-style warlord.

        As for the Bard, Atwill makes a fairly convincing case that at least some of Shakespeare was a “counter-literature” written against the New Testament stories.

Comments are closed.

If you have Paywall access,
simply login first to see your comment auto-approved.

Note on comments privacy & moderation

Your email is never published nor shared.

Comments are moderated. If you don't see your comment, please be patient. If approved, it will appear here soon. Do not post your comment a second time.

  • Recent posts

    • Animals & Children First

      Jim Goad

      22

    • The Great Replacement Prize

      Greg Johnson

    • Remembering Julius Evola
      (May 19, 1898–June 11, 1974)

      Greg Johnson

    • Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 445
      The Writers’ Bloc with Kathryn S. on Mircea Eliade

      Counter-Currents Radio

      1

    • O Manifesto Nacionalista Branco:
      Parte 1, Introdução

      Greg Johnson

    • Extremities:
      A Film from Long Ago that Anticipated Today’s Woke Hollywood

      Stephen Paul Foster

      6

    • The National Health Service:
      My Part in Its Downfall

      Mark Gullick

      9

    • Male Supremacism in the United States?

      Margot Metroland

      2

    • Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 444
      Ask Me Anything with Greg Johnson

      Counter-Currents Radio

      1

    • Fallen Castes

      Thomas Steuben

      14

    • Work to Be Such a Man

      Morris van de Camp

      6

    • Be a Medici:
      New Patrons for a New Renaissance

      Robert Wallace

      17

    • Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 443
      Interview with Jim Goad

      Counter-Currents Radio

    • Das Manifest des weißen Nationalismus:
      Teil 5, Die Wiederherstellung Unserer Weissen Heimatländer

      Greg Johnson

    • Where Do We Go from Buffalo?

      Jim Goad

      42

    • Rammstein’s Deutschland

      Ondrej Mann

      6

    • If I Lost Hope

      Greg Johnson

      5

    • Das Manifest des weißen Nationalismus:
      Teil 4, Wie Können Wir den Weissen Genozid Beenden?

      Greg Johnson

    • Payton Gendron & the Buffalo Massacre

      Greg Johnson

      63

    • The Counter-Currents 2022 Fundraiser
      Between Now and May 20th, Give a New Monthly Gift and Receive a New Book!

      Cyan Quinn

    • This Weekend’s Livestreams
      Jim Goad on Counter-Currents Radio & Kathryn S. on The Writers’ Bloc

      Greg Johnson

    • Remembering Hinton Rowan Helper

      Spencer J. Quinn

      11

    • Make Art Great Again:
      The Good Optics of Salvador Dalí, Part 3

      James J. O'Meara

    • Babette’s Feast

      Nicholas R. Jeelvy

      1

    • Das Manifest des weißen Nationalismus:
      Teil 3, Weisser Völkermord

      Greg Johnson

    • Hey, Portland Synagogue Vandal — Whatcha Doin’?

      Jim Goad

      26

    • The Pro-Dysgenics Agenda

      Robert Hampton

      29

    • Make Art Great Again:
      The Good Optics of Salvador Dalí, Part 2

      James J. O'Meara

      4

    • Das Manifest des weißen Nationalismus:
      Teil 2, Weisses Aussterben

      Greg Johnson

    • Now Available!
      The Enemy of Europe

      Francis Parker Yockey

    • Now Available!
      Trevor Lynch’s Classics of Right-Wing Cinema

      Trevor Lynch

      1

    • Now Available!
      Jonathan Bowden’s Reactionary Modernism

      Jonathan Bowden

    • Why the Central European Elites Love War

      Petr Hampl

      34

    • Make Art Great Again:
      The Good Optics of Salvador Dalí, Part 1

      James J. O'Meara

      1

    • Memelord Dalí
      Remembering Salvador Dalí
      (May 11, 1904–January 23, 1989)

      Nicholas R. Jeelvy

    • Morality Death Match:
      Lecter vs. Chigurh

      Mark Gullick

      2

    • Why I Write, Part II:
      Farewell to My Friend Robin

      Richard Houck

      16

    • Put Many Tools into the Toolbox

      Morris van de Camp

      4

    • Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 442
      Ask Me Anything with Greg Johnson

      Counter-Currents Radio

      2

    • Das Manifest des weißen Nationalismus:
      Teil 1, Einführung

      Greg Johnson

    • The Worst Week Yet:
      May 1-7, 2022

      Jim Goad

      39

    • Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 441
      Interview with Richard Houck on Roe v. Wade

      Counter-Currents Radio

    • Some Thoughts on the Hume-Rousseau “Philosopher’s Quarrel”

      Stephen Paul Foster

      5

    • My Midlife Crisis

      Greg Johnson

      10

    • Interview mit Breizh-info

      Greg Johnson

    • Mother’s Day Special

      Cyan Quinn

      2

    • This Weekend’s Livestreams
      Tonight’s Episode of The Writers’ Bloc Cancelled

      Greg Johnson

    • The Counter-Currents 2022 Fundraiser
      Now You Can Make Monthly Donations with E-Checks!

      Greg Johnson

    • Critique as Empire-Killer

      Nicholas R. Jeelvy

      11

    • Simon Webb & Patriotic Alternative

      Spencer J. Quinn

      12

  • Recent comments

    • Shift Animals & Children First Mexicans behind me have a rooster that crows all day.  I dig it!  
    • mark gullick The National Health Service:
      My Part in Its Downfall
      The lead-paint boy. Form a band, Margot. Call it that.
    • mark gullick The National Health Service:
      My Part in Its Downfall
      I thought it was Shelley, but I am known for what the English call cock-ups.
    • mark gullick The National Health Service:
      My Part in Its Downfall
      Philosophy. It gets us all in the end, my friend...
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First According to the actual definition of “species”—a group of organisms capable of producing offspring...
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First Hispanics and whites have roughly equivalent rates of pet ownership. Hispanics actually have a...
    • Pet lover Animals & Children First White people have a peculiar attachment to pets (dogs/cats) because they are either surrogate...
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First Cookie, whose AKC name was Duchess of Cookwich. I hand-delivered all nine of her puppies and made...
    • Tony Animals & Children First Jim, if you are claiming biological and evolutionary kinship with Lil’ Wayne, Jessamyn Stanley,...
    • Shift Animals & Children First Cookie
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First "Christians like to imply that 'materialists' or 'Darwinists' are cruel bastards, but that’s just...
    • La-Z-Man Animals & Children First My wife tells me she saw our cat playing around with a rat in our backyard. This is night time. I...
    • James J. O'Meara Animals & Children First Indeed.  Our rude ancestors have much to answer for.  A. Jacob observes that "In his late essay...
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First What does that have to do with Junior?
    • Jim Goad Animals & Children First Yeah, well, that "narrow, strictly taxonomic sense" is also the dictionary definition of the word,...
    • La-Z-Man Extremities:
      A Film from Long Ago that Anticipated Today’s Woke Hollywood
      Thank you! I just knew Fawcett played in a movie about an abusive relationship, but the title...
    • J Wilcox Animals & Children First Humans and pets have partly co-evolved to be both family and work partners.  Dogs still have...
    • Vehmgericht Animals & Children First Bloody sacrifices were a mainstay of religion in classical antiquity: the Spartans would not give...
    • La-Z-Man The National Health Service:
      My Part in Its Downfall
      Wow, talk about synchronicity! Only this week I learned the Solzhenitsyn quote about poets being the...
    • tito perdue Animals & Children First 'The black girl may be the same species as me..." I wouldn't go as far as that. .
  • Books

    • Kerry Bolton
    • Jonathan Bowden
    • Buttercup Dew
    • Collin Cleary
    • Jef Costello
    • F. Roger Devlin
    • Julius Evola
    • Gregory Hood
    • Juleigh Howard-Hobson
    • Greg Johnson
    • Jason Jorjani
    • Ward Kendall
    • Anthony M. Ludovici
    • Trevor Lynch
    • H. L. Mencken
    • J. A. Nicholl
    • Andy Nowicki
    • James J. O'Meara
    • Michael O'Meara
    • Christopher Pankhurst
    • Tito Perdue
    • Michael Polignano
    • Spencer J. Quinn
    • Savitri Devi
    • Fenek Solère
    • Irmin Vinson
    • Leo Yankevich
    • Francis Parker Yockey
  • Webzine Authors

    Contemporary authors

    • Howe Abbott-Hiss
    • Beau Albrecht
    • Aquilonius
    • Anthony Bavaria
    • Michael Bell
    • Alain de Benoist
    • Kerry Bolton
    • Jonathan Bowden
    • Buttercup Dew
    • Collin Cleary
    • Giles Corey
    • Jef Costello
    • Morris V. de Camp
    • F. Roger Devlin
    • Bain Dewitt
    • Jack Donovan
    • Ricardo Duchesne
    • Émile Durand
    • Guillaume Durocher
    • Mark Dyal
    • Guillaume Faye
    • Stephen Paul Foster
    • Fullmoon Ancestry
    • Jim Goad
    • Tom Goodrich
    • Alex Graham
    • Mark Gullick
    • Andrew Hamilton
    • Robert Hampton
    • Huntley Haverstock
    • Derek Hawthorne
    • Gregory Hood
    • Juleigh Howard-Hobson
    • Richard Houck
    • Alexander Jacob
    • Nicholas R. Jeelvy
    • Greg Johnson
    • Ruuben Kaalep
    • Tobias Langdon
    • Julian Langness
    • Travis LeBlanc
    • Patrick Le Brun
    • Trevor Lynch
    • Kevin MacDonald
    • G. A. Malvicini
    • John Michael McCloughlin
    • Margot Metroland
    • Millennial Woes
    • John Morgan
    • James J. O'Meara
    • Michael O'Meara
    • Christopher Pankhurst
    • Michael Polignano
    • J. J. Przybylski
    • Spencer J. Quinn
    • Quintilian
    • Edouard Rix
    • C. B. Robertson
    • C. F. Robinson
    • Hervé Ryssen
    • Kathryn S.
    • Alan Smithee
    • Fenek Solère
    • Ann Sterzinger
    • Thomas Steuben
    • Robert Steuckers
    • Tomislav Sunić
    • Donald Thoresen
    • Marian Van Court
    • Dominique Venner
    • Irmin Vinson
    • Michael Walker
    • Aylmer Wedgwood
    • Scott Weisswald
    • Leo Yankevich

    Classic Authors

    • Maurice Bardèche
    • Julius Evola
    • Ernst Jünger
    • D. H. Lawrence
    • Charles Lindbergh
    • Jack London
    • H. P. Lovecraft
    • Anthony M. Ludovici
    • Sir Oswald Mosley
    • National Vanguard
    • Friedrich Nietzsche
    • Revilo Oliver
    • William Pierce
    • Ezra Pound
    • Saint-Loup
    • Savitri Devi
    • Carl Schmitt
    • Miguel Serrano
    • Oswald Spengler
    • P. R. Stephensen
    • Jean Thiriart
    • John Tyndall
    • Francis Parker Yockey
  • Departments

    • Book Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV Reviews
    • Music Reviews
    • Art Criticism
    • Graphic Novels & Comics
    • Video Game Reviews
    • Fiction
    • Poems
    • Interviews
    • Videos
    • English Translations
    • Other Languages
      • Arabic
      • Bulgarian
      • Croatian
      • Czech
      • Danish
      • Dutch
      • Estonian
      • Finnish
      • French
      • German
      • Greek
      • Hungarian
      • Italian
      • Lithuanian
      • Norwegian
      • Polish
      • Portuguese
      • Romanian
      • Russian
      • Slovak
      • Spanish
      • Swedish
      • Ukrainian
    • Commemorations
    • Why We Write
  • Archives
  • Top 100 Commenters
Sponsored Links
Alaska Chaga Antelope Hill Publishing Imperium Press American Renaissance A Dissident’s Guide to Blacks and Africa The Patrick Ryan Show Jim Goad The Occidental Observer
Editor-in-Chief
Greg Johnson
Books for sale
  • Trevor Lynch’s Classics of Right-Wing Cinema
  • The Enemy of Europe
  • Imperium
  • Reactionary Modernism
  • Manifesto del Nazionalismo Bianco
  • O Manifesto Nacionalista Branco
  • Vade Mecum
  • Whiteness: The Original Sin
  • Space Vixen Trek Episode 17: Tomorrow the Stars
  • The Year America Died
  • Passing the Buck
  • Mysticism After Modernism
  • Gold in the Furnace
  • Defiance
  • Forever & Ever
  • Wagner’s Ring & the Germanic Tradition
  • Resistance
  • Materials for All Future Historians
  • Love Song of the Australopiths
  • White Identity Politics
  • Here’s the Thing
  • Trevor Lynch: Part Four of the Trilogy
  • Graduate School with Heidegger
  • It’s Okay to Be White
  • The World in Flames
  • The White Nationalist Manifesto
  • From Plato to Postmodernism
  • The Gizmo
  • Return of the Son of Trevor Lynch’s CENSORED Guide to the Movies
  • Toward a New Nationalism
  • The Smut Book
  • The Alternative Right
  • My Nationalist Pony
  • Dark Right: Batman Viewed From the Right
  • The Philatelist
  • Confessions of an Anti-Feminist
  • East and West
  • Though We Be Dead, Yet Our Day Will Come
  • White Like You
  • Numinous Machines
  • Venus and Her Thugs
  • Cynosura
  • North American New Right, vol. 2
  • You Asked For It
  • More Artists of the Right
  • Extremists: Studies in Metapolitics
  • The Homo & the Negro
  • Rising
  • The Importance of James Bond
  • In Defense of Prejudice
  • Confessions of a Reluctant Hater (2nd ed.)
  • The Hypocrisies of Heaven
  • Waking Up from the American Dream
  • Green Nazis in Space!
  • Truth, Justice, and a Nice White Country
  • Heidegger in Chicago
  • The End of an Era
  • Sexual Utopia in Power
  • What is a Rune? & Other Essays
  • Son of Trevor Lynch’s White Nationalist Guide to the Movies
  • The Lightning & the Sun
  • The Eldritch Evola
  • Western Civilization Bites Back
  • New Right vs. Old Right
  • Journey Late at Night: Poems and Translations
  • The Non-Hindu Indians & Indian Unity
  • Baader Meinhof ceramic pistol, Charles Kraaft 2013
  • Pulp Fascism
  • The Lost Philosopher, Second Expanded Edition
  • Trevor Lynch’s A White Nationalist Guide to the Movies
  • And Time Rolls On
  • Artists of the Right
  • North American New Right, Vol. 1
  • Some Thoughts on Hitler
  • Tikkun Olam and Other Poems
  • Summoning the Gods
  • Taking Our Own Side
  • Reuben
  • The Node
  • The New Austerities
  • Morning Crafts
  • The Passing of a Profit & Other Forgotten Stories
  • Rss
  • DLive
  • Telegram
  • Gab
  • Entropy
Copyright © 2022 Counter-Currents Publishing, Ltd.

Paywall Access





Please enter your email address. You will receive mail with link to set new password.

Edit your comment