Counter-Currents
767 words
The Amazon purge of the Dissident Right continues. We need to assemble resources for fighting back. Thus I am asking readers to share the following pieces of information. Please post them in the comments below, and I will paste them in the body of this document. I will not, of course, reveal your identity in any way.
1. Titles Banned: Author, Title, and Formats (HC, PB, eBook, audiobook)
2. Contact Emails and Phone Numbers to Complain to Amazon (Boycotting won’t help if they don’t know why you are doing it.)
3. Experiences with Kindles (Have Kindles of banned books been removed from your devices?)
4. Experiences of Amazon Marketplace Sellers (Have you been harassed in any way by Amazon for stocking the titles they are now banning?)
5. Memes & Templates to Share
Titles Banned (54 and Counting)
Counter-Currents Publishing titles:
- Greg Johnson, The White Nationalist Manifesto (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Greg Johnson, New Right vs. Old Right (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Greg Johnson, Truth, Justice, and a Nice White Country (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Greg Johnson, In Defence of Prejudice (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Greg Johnson, ed., North American New Right, vol. 1 (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Greg Johnson, ed., North American New Right, vol. 2 (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Trevor Lynch’s White Nationalist Guide to the Movies (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Son of Trevor Lynch’s White Nationalist Guide to the Movies (Kindle)
- Roger Devlin, Sexual Utopia in Power (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Jonathan Bowden, Western Civilization Bites Back (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Jonathan Bowden, Extremists: Studies in Metapolitics (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Michael Polignano, Taking Our Own Side (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- James J. O’Meara, The Homo and the Negro: Masculinist Meditations on Politics and Popular Culture (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Spencer Quinn, White Like You (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Savitri Devi, And Time Rolls On (Kindle, HC, and PB)
- Savitri Devi, Defiance: The Prison Memoirs of Savitri Devi (Kindle)
- Irmin Vinson, Some Thoughts on Hitler & Other Essays (Kindle, HC, and PB)
New Century Foundation:
- Jared Taylor, White Identity (all formats)
- Jared Taylor, If We Do Nothing (all formats)
- Jared Taylor, ed., Face to Face with Race (all formats)
- Jared Taylor and George McDaniel, eds., A Race Against Time (all formats)
Kevin MacDonald titles:
- The Culture of Critique (all formats)
- Separation and Its Discontents (all formats)
Black House Publishing:
- K. R. Bolton, Zionism, Islam and the West (all formats)
- Stephen Mitford Goodson, A History of Central Banking & the Enslavement of Mankind (all formats)
- Stephen Mitford Goodson, Inside the South African Reserve Bank: Its Origins and Secrets Exposed (all formats)
George Lincoln Rockwell:
- This Time the World (all formats)
- White Power (all formats)
- Collected Works (all formats)
- A National Socialist Life (all formats)
William Pierce:
- The Turner Diaries (all formats)
- Hunter (all formats)
- Who We Are (all formats)
- Cosmotheism (all formats)
Harold Covington:
- The Brigade (all formats)
- Freedom’s Sons (all formats)
- A Mighty Fortress (all formats)
- Hill of the Ravens (all formats)
- A Distant Thunder (all formats)
- Dreaming the Iron Dream (all formats)
- The March Up Country (all formats)
- The White Book (all formats)
Ben Klassen:
- Nature’s Eternal Religion (all formats)
- The White Man’s Bible (all formats)
- Little White Book (all formats)
Miscellaneous Titles:
- Tommy Robinson, Mohammed’s Koran (all formats)
- Julian Langness, Identity Rising (all formats)
- David Duke, My Awakening (Kindle)
- Christopher Jon Bjerknes, E = Mc2 and the Jewish Agenda (all formats)
- E. Michael Jones, Jewish Nazis (all formats)
- The Secret Relationship Between Blacks and Jews, vol. 1
- The Secret Relationship Between Blacks and Jews, vol. 2
- The Secret Relationship Between Blacks and Jews, vol. 3
- Colin Flaherty, Don’t Make the Black Kids Angry
Here is a list of Holocaust revisionist books banned by Amazon in a previous purge.
2. Contacting Amazon
Please keep your complaints brief, polite, and factually accurate. Anything less does not help the cause.
3. Kindle Experiences
One reader in the US reports that the Kindle of David Duke’s My Awakening has been removed from his device. A second reader reports the deletion of unspecified titles by Harold Covington. Two other readers report no loss of CC titles.
4. Amazon Marketplace Experiences
One Amazon Marketplace seller reports being contacted to inform him that one Counter-Currents title and one Jared Taylor title that he had listed but sold had been removed from sale. He was informed that he had to close or delete his listings of these titles under threat of having his seller privileges revoked. Amazon’s communication was badly worded and ambiguous — ironic that semi-literate people work for the world’s biggest bookseller book banner — but it illustrates the crack brained totalitarian hysteria of this purge. Why do Amazon Marketplace sellers have to delete records of books? Can’t Amazon.com do that? And why would it even be necessary, given that the pages for these titles have been completely removed in the first place?
5. Memes & Templates to Share
82 comments
“Have Kindles of banned books been removed from your devices?”
No, I still have all them. (I think my purchases fall under EU jurisdiction.)
‘Experiences with Kindles (Have Kindles of banned books been removed from your devices?)’
Not as yet but its happened to previous ‘controversial’ books ive owned
The Six Million: Fact or Fiction by Peter Winter is definitely banned. This is a list by Barnes Review.
https://barnesreview.org/product-category/banned-by-amazon/
The Myth of German Villainy by Benton Bradberry is banned
Book depository from Britain still has these ‘banned’ books. Free shipping too. They are sometimes slow though.
FYI: The Alternative Right and The White Nationalist Manifesto still show in my Kindle Library online at Amazon. I pre-ordered both as I recall, or at least bought them the day they were available. I was able to download both to my PC today, as well.
Best Wishes,
Guy
When Greg’s White Nationalist Manifesto was released, I thought, ‘I should purchase this and a bunch of other CC titles on Kindle, as they are in danger of being shoahed.’
This was only days ago. I’m sorry to say this fear came true. I am only missing 4 of CC’s titles from the above list. And I never got around to getting Covington’s books….
This must be devastating for you Greg. But it was always going to happen. The censorship will only get worse, and there is no situation where these jew run digital companies will reverse bans for evil racists.
So you must setup a method of being able to purchase PDF copies of your books on this website. Not many people want to buy physical copies of books anymore. I say this as someone who has 8 Ikea Billy bookshelves full of books. Even I now use Kindle and ebook readers.
Not many people want to buy physical copies of books anymore.
But some of us do. It’s the only way we will read a book.
You understand, there was a lot of antitrust talk about amazon before certain books were banned. Remember that? The books were banned and now amazon owns Whole Foods. It’s a brilliant strategy really. The government is coercing the private companies to engage in repression for it. This is what’s happening with the tech people too, although I imagine their heart was always there anyway. Did Lincoln Rockwell—a true “Nazi”—ever have difficulty for example opening a bank account? Could everyone simply arbitrarily refuse someone financial services? It’s got to be illegal at some level.
US Kindle Store: WN Manifesto and “Liberalism Unmasked” still show up for me.
Oops meant the kindle library (online), not the store. I don’t see them for sale, but for now the already purchased ones remain available for me to read.
Race and the American Prospect
The Real American Dilemma
I can confirm Kindles disappearing, in my case HA Covington. I didn’t have an overpriced Kindle copy of My Awakening.
There are still pages for these books.
You need to be specific about what formats are disappearing.
Which Covington titles, specifically? I am sure there are Covington and Rockwell titles that I do not list above that have been removed. I would like to know specifically so we can get an accurate count.
The Northwest Quintet, all formats for most, HC of The Brigade still listed.
North American New Right volume 2 has also been banned.
North American New Right volume 2 has also been banned.
USA jurisdiction for Amazon and Kindle.
Thanks
Any idea what spurred this frantic quest to remove these books all of a sudden?
My guess is that their earnings report on april the 25th. Amazon virtue signalling to its customers about how they ban all ‘hate’ on their platform, no doubt.
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s 200 Years Together (all formats: only Russian-language HC is still sold)
Did they really just get rid of that work, or has it been available now for awhile?
Because Solzhenitsyn isn’t even really anti-Semitic as far as I’m aware and I’m having a hard time seeing them removing a more acedemically focused work like his that nobody under IQ 115 is even going to’ve heard of.
Not calling you a liar, just very surprised if that were actually the case— hard to believe even Amazon would go THIS far.
The Gulag Archipelago is still available BTW
I bought an English Kindle edition of 200 Years Ago last month. I don’t know when in that time it was removed.
Find out who harassed Amazon to get rid of the titles and have them explain why they want white nationalist literature removed and not the literature of terrorists and other evildoers. Invite them to debate Jared Taylor Greg Johnson. I have a feeling that they are afraid and know that they will be defeated.
E. Michael Jones’s book “Jewish Nazis” was removed from Amazon on Tuesday. Here’s the update from Fidelity Press:
“Amazon has removed E. Michael Jones’s e-book Jewish Nazis from sale, telling us “we found that the subject matter of the following book is in violation of our content guidelines.”
“(If you previously purchased this e-book on Amazon, please let us know whether Amazon has also removed it from your Kindle. Thank you.)”
I canceled my prime account 2 days before it was to renew because of this and the Counter Currents purge.
Thanks
Nobody died at sandy hook was removed a few years ago. Kindle editions were included i believe. I stopped using amazon years ago due to their sabotaging other businesses. Their censorship hasnt surprised me. Its the same reason Bezos took the boards off on imdb. Same reason he bought createspace. Stop the truth from spreading.
They removed a slew that made any inquiries into the greatest hoax.
Great – no tax to Amazon for the distribution of esoteric, authoritarian, anti-egalitarian masterpieces. I for one will go elsewhere.
100% legit source for Thelema-related books not available on Amazon.
http://concreat.org/shop/
Nation of Islam’s “The Secret Relationship Between Blacks and Jews” are also banned:
https://revisionistreview.blogspot.com/2019/03/amazon-bans-black-history-books-during.html
Amazon’s Australian site has removed the White Nationalist Manifesto, but the copy I bought is still on my Kindle. ‘Confessions’ and ‘The Alternative Right’ are still available for sale.
Neither of the Trevor Lynch movie review compilations are available, but Dark Right is still being sold.
Of James O’Meara’s works, Homo is gone but Green Nazis, Aryan Imperium, the Mad Men book and Magick remain.
It should be noted that some titles were previously not available through the Australian site, so it’s difficult to tell what’s been removed vs what was never there.
.
JOM’s “Green Nazis In Space” was a good book. Only downside was that a good portion of it was spent commenting on various movies I’d never seen. Obviously, get the paperback version if you’re going to.
Amazon must be a happy merchant.
Hey Greg, here’s the meme.
https://i.imgur.com/UVCciY9.jpg
Sorry for poor quality since I didn’t have access to PC, perhaps someone can remake it better.
Nice. Send it to Greg’s email.
He saw it I think, I assume he moderates the comment section, no?
I have a few of the titles on Kindle. The items still appear in my library and are there in my order history. But the Amazon pages are no longer there.
This is really outrageous. Free speech includes not only the right to write what you want, but also the right to READ what you want. Whatever happened to consenting adults! Much of the material or at least the ideas will still be around online, but this will choke off yet another source of revenue going forward.
Just to give a sense of the bizarro world we live in, I want to point out that the American Library Association keeps a list of so-called “banned books.” Most of the titles were challenged for use in schools specifically, often by conservative parents who saw some of the books as being too profane or explicit for youth to be reading. But not wanting your elementary schooler reading “Daddy’s Roommate” in school isn’t exactly a ban. Such supposedly suppressed books have always been readily available for purchase and in fact the only thing being challenged is their artificial promotion in the school system.
http://www.ala.org/advocacy/bbooks/frequentlychallengedbooks/top10
In contrast, here we are seeing books being straight up banned for purchase. They rationalize this as not really being banned because you could in theory try to sell pdf files from your own website or start your own competing ebook service or something. Beyond ridiculous.
Two more Rockwell collection:
George Lincoln Rockwell – Collected Works (all formats)
https://www.amazon.com/Collected-Works-George-Lincoln-Rockwell/dp/168418326X
George Lincoln Rockwell – A National Socialist Life (all formats)
https://www.amazon.com/National-Socialist-Life-Selected-Writings/dp/1460989120
Who We Are by William L. Pierce (all formats)
FWIW: I just installed a clean (i.e. empty) kindle reader on my laptop, and had no problems in downloading a copy of my previously bought TWNM.
That is good
Can you just open an account as a used book seller and sell the books that way?
No because they have taken down the product pages, so nobody can buy the books in any format, used or new. They are also harrassing sellers to delete their used listings.
William Pierce’s Cosmotheism (all formats) disappeared since Friday.
Covington’s Dreaming The Iron Dream has been removed.
The Bad War by M.S. King (banned before)
The Myth of German Villany by Benton L. Bradberry (still listed but Amazon not selling as pod)
Looking at some of your comments, I am glad I only buy physical copies of books. It is the only way I will read a book. People that only read electronic books are too easy to censor.
The answer I was given by Amazon was the title “Western Civilization Bites Back” was that the seller has made this unavailable to amazon. I bought this book through amazon last summer.
Yeah, well that is simply not true. Amazon is making it unavailable to you.
The page for Michael Hoffman’s Judaism’s Strange Gods (all versions, print and kindle) was removed in late 2018. There’s still a page for an older edition, of which only used copies are available.
This censorship is getting worse day by day!!… And still people have the nerve, the gall of calling this “Democracy”!…
To paraphrase Hans Hermann Hoppe: democracy is merely a soft variant of communism.
Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner. Liberty is a well armed sheep contesting the vote.
There’s nothing inherently contradictory about a democratic regime banning books, placing certain types of people into concentration camps (E.G., the Japanese during WWII, Socrates trial & execution!), etc. That’s actually the main idea of democracy, a sort of moral relativism wherein good or evil is determined by majority consensus.
Of course, where it is hypocritical is wherein democracy self-defines its self as “liberty for all to do as they wish” when the entire basis of the system is contradictory of that. However, I get what you mean.
Ironically, all of these bans are leaving The Culture of Critique at the top of the list on almost every conservative and Rightist book listing. With any luck it will bring fame to his work and engender mass redpilling on the real problem (or the root of the problem). Once that ‘question’ is answered, the answers to the others are obvious – and no one answers it with greater elan than Dr MacDonald.
‘All things work together for the good of them that love God’
Culture of Critique has now been banned as well.
Dreaming the Iron Dream by Covington got the axe over the weekend, too. It was still available when the Quintet was banned.
Why hasn’t the ban of Solzhenitsyn in English (all formats of 200 Years) gone on the list? That’s the biggest shock of the bunch, and Solzhenitsyn is mainstream. But he dared criticize the tribe.
How about his March Up Country? Was that on Amazon at one time?
Were any of Covington’s non-NW novels banned?
Covington/Northwest Front’s ‘White Book’ has also been banned. I know it was never supposed to be available except to members of the NF but Amazon sold two editions (both PB) of it until recently. The pages are missing.
I don’t know about March Up Country. I never read it or bought it, and I bought every Covington novel I could on Amazon in 2016 (assuming Amazon stocked all of them), and never got that one, which is presumptive evidence they didn’t stock it then.
Fire and Rain and Slow Coming Dark (the Redmond prequels) and The Black Flame are still available.
I can only speak for Amazon UK but March up Country was in my basket and is now gone. It is now banned.
His fictional novels outside of the Quintet are all available at the moment.
I have access to my cloud copy of WNM.
The feedback from Amazon keeps claiming that only the author and publisher knows why it’s unavailable on its site.
On a positive note for those who prefer to shop online with gift cards, the WNM is available on ebay (for a while anyways).
About censorship. It is not just the prowhite crusade feeling the sting. Vaccine truth organizations are in the crosshairs as well, and it is getting bad. The queen bee of the National Vaccine Information Center, Barbara Loe Fisher, has made a youtube video (how long will it be there, I wonder) describing censorship and what those opposed to mandatory vaccination are facing – and what they will have to do. And that it applies to everyone, not just those opposed to mandatory innoculation.
From her video:
“Has the internet been hijacked by Wall Street? It sure looks that way. An electronic wall is being built to block you from getting information you want so you get only the information someone else decides you need. An electronic burning of the books has begun and the people are being silently herded into a virtual dark age. While this conversation is starting about health and vaccination, it will not end there. Those who have bought and controlled internet now have the power to restrict or block any kind of information they do not want you to see or talk about with your family, friends and others you connect with online.
So who is doing the judging of what is truth and what is “fake news” online?
…
In this time of oppression, we cannot know what needs to be done unless we go forward with our eyes wide open, understanding the new reality without fearing it. It is time to collect, preserve and cherish the good books, articles, films, videos and podcasts that have been published about vaccination and share them with our family and friends; time to save and download to our computers and external hard drives the written and video information still online that we want to keep and share with our children and our grandchildren. Time to expand the open public record by attending, testifying at and recording every legislative hearing, every town hall gathering, and every federal vaccine advisory committee meeting where people discuss vaccination or attempt to eliminate the human right to autonomy and censor freedom of thought and speech.”
https://www.nvic.org/NVIC-Vaccine-News/December-2018/internet-police-protect-you-from-freedom-of-speech.aspx
What this speaker has to say applies to us here as well.
PS. I am not hijacking your topic in order to present my other “little” hobby-horse, which claim has been made in the past here a few years ago. This IS about us. Thank you kindly.
I’d venture to guess that the danger of vaccines is vastly over-stated, because the amount of dangerous chemicals you receive from vaccines is a drop in the bucket compared to all the dangerous chemicals you get from your everyday diet– E.G., xeno-estrogens, BPA-like chemicals, RX runoff in the tap water, pollution in the air, etc in far, far, far higher amounts.
I’d venture to guess the biggest conspiracy regarding vaccines is a conspiracy of Big Pharma to make more money by selling you unnecessary shots.
We hear, for instance, of trace amounts of mercury present in vaccines. However, how much more mercury would someone who eats a tuna sandwich once a week take into his body over the course of a year? I have no idea, but I’d rekon far more.
That said though, I’d also venture to guess they’re targeting anti-vax conspiracy theorists because they’re a “soft target” that will be used to set a precedent for going after other “dangerous ideas” in the future, same with the Moon landing and Flat Earth conspiracy theorists.
Additionally, “subversive” ideas tend to travel in packs, and the “Domino Theory” of questioning the system– people who question 1 or 2 mainstream ideas are far more likely to question others, leading down a dangerous rabbit hole.
Additionally, “subversive” ideas tend to travel in packs, and the “Domino Theory” of questioning the system– people who question 1 or 2 mainstream ideas are far more likely to question others, leading down a dangerous rabbit hole.
That is correct. That’s the point. But that does not entitle anyone to ignore the realities of socalled innoculation. They only thing vaccines innoculate anyone against is the possibility of good health. However, in Amerikwa, as long as you can stand upright, and maybe go to work every day, that’s all you require to be considered healthy. You can be taking 10 prescription drugs to keep the Angel of Death from your door (for awhile) and you’re still “healthy”.
I’d venture to guess that the danger of vaccines is vastly over-stated, because the amount of dangerous chemicals you receive from vaccines is a drop in the bucket compared to all the dangerous chemicals you get from your everyday diet…
It’s not “you” receiving vaccine-borne chemicals, it’s babies and growing children. About 54 doses by the time they are 18 years of age, and starting at 2 months of age. And more in some cases.
Have the last word. Just wanted to remind you once again that you and your “subversive” ideas are next down the line, maybe they already are, which you of course know. But it’s not your ox being gored with the vaccine issue, is it, so don’t worry. Get your kids poked if you want and your precious annual Flu Shot too. But while I’m here, maybe you could let me know why the US government has a Vaccine Injury Compensation Plan, the purpose of which is to hold vaccine mfrs unaccountable, this plan having paid out $4,000,000,000 to date. You’re paying for it.
Ben Klassen’s Nature’s Eternal Religion, White Man’s Bible, and Little White Book have all three been banned (all formats). They were available in PB and Kindle.
I think Klassen was a raving madman and a disasset to the movement, but nevertheless, his books should not be banned.
Yeah, its a double-edged sword.
E.G., almost the entirety of WN 1.0 (e.g., GLR, Stormfront, etc) are liabilities. Dudes with really cringy ideas that present very, very bad optics and hinder us more than help.
You look at Europe, where they don’t have a 1st Amendment and hate speech is banned, and you see far more articulate, well dressed, and sane-sounding right-wing movements, such as Generation Identity.
You look at America, where any yahoo can speak his mind, and you see all this cringy sperging that turns off normies.
I don’t like the idea of any censorship, whether its of Nazis, communists, feminists, or what-have-you. This shouldn’t be happening. However, we can’t deny the double edge of the free speech sword.
I just checked my kindle now and the WN Manifesto is still on it.
We can still purchase many of these directly from counter-currents, correct?
I agree with one of the above posters, now qe are obligated as free white men and women to own this entire list. If the powers that be ban something, consider it an endorsement-it must be the truth.
Regards
Yes you can buy all CC books here except for titles that are out of print.
I bought my copy of The White Nationalist Manifesto last October from Alibris.com. Reason: They had the best price. Alibris still carries the book, by the way.
FYI, I have two on the ban list still available on my Kindle(s).
And here’s a potential idea for CC staff . . .
Contact this Trib reporter, remind him of his column last fall during “banned books week.”
https://www.chicagotribune.com/lifestyles/books/ct-books-biblioracle-0930-20180925-story.html
See if he’ll put his $ (job) where his mouth (opening paragraph) is. Moreover, track down any other journalist who wrote similar paeans to free expression during that annual exercise in leftist sanctimony.
Getting just one to do an expose on Amazonian censorship, particularly in light of Sen. Warren’s recent proposal to regulate big tech, may help the cause with earned media.
Tall order, no doubt, but may turn up the rare old-school liberal who recalls the days when 1A issues transcended ideology and also may find the anti-corporatocracy angle appealing.
Of course, always keeping Hunter S. Thompson’s definition of journalism*, along with (((who))) controls the media, at top of mind.
*https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/31525-the-press-is-a-gang-of-cruel-faggots-journalism-is
Excellent idea
Where can I buy Mohammed’s Koran?
Here: http://www.mohammeds-koran.com
They have removed The Culture of Critique and Separation and Its Discontents from Amazon.co.uk
A People That Shall Dwell Alone is still available.
Dr. Kevin MacDonald: Amazon Bans Culture of Critique and Separation and Its Discontents
https://www.theoccidentalobserver.net/2019/03/12/amazon-bans-culture-of-critique-and-separation-and-its-discontents/
MacDonald’s Culture of Critique and SAID have both been banned. The top result for ‘Culture of Critique’ is now ‘An Aftocentric Critique of European Thought and Culture’ ????????????????????????
Amazon has gone too far. I’ve canceled all of my subs and orders. This is beyond belief.
Understanding Jewish Influence and Cultural Insurtections have also been banned.
Maybe someone will finally believe me that Solzhenitsyn’s criticism of the thrice-damned tribe and their baneful influence actually was banned during this rollup now!
‘The Case for Israel’ and ‘The Israel Test’ are both available. Now we know who is behind these efforts: the longnoses and Dees.
As long as MacDonald was still available people would have eventually come to the truth on all cultural and ethnic questions. Now, if one goes through all of Amazon, one would think they’ve never been asked, and people will remain silent, thinking they’re the only one who has ever thought it. There is now no criticism of the Tribe available on Amazon, and most of the searches have been manipulated to return doubleplus goodthink books in the top results.
I predicted this. Look for them to ban ‘self-hating Jews’ like Shahak and Finkelstein next.
You can add Kevin Macdonald’s books to that list now as well. At least by doing all of this the USUAL SUSPECTS are making it easier and easier to piece together who controls this society.
I advertise books on my site and I noticed four missing now.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DarkEnlightenment/comments/b0rtm6/amazon_bans_culture_of_critique_and_separation/eihs0g2/
Face to face with race by jared taylor
Don’t make the black kids angry by colin flaherty
sexual utopia in power by f. rodger devlin
western civilisation by jonathon bowden
Turner Diaries is still available
Banning books makes you want to buy them. Banning books subconsciously avails their theses, whatever that may be. These fools really don’t get it.
Comments are closed.
If you have Paywall access,
simply login first to see your comment auto-approved.
Note on comments privacy & moderation
Your email is never published nor shared.
Comments are moderated. If you don't see your comment, please be patient. If approved, it will appear here soon. Do not post your comment a second time.
Paywall Access
Edit your comment