C. F. Robinson
The Only Holiday Unique to the American Ethny
There is no holiday or tradition that is both solemn and as deeply intertwined in the unique historical American ethnicity and spiritualism as Thanksgiving. The holiday has several meanings. The first is religious. The Mayflower Pilgrims celebrated their survival in Plymouth Colony with a feast and gave thanks to God for their blessings. Today, deep within American culture, Thanksgiving still carries the impulse to give thanks to the Almighty for one’s blessings during the year. Additionally, the holiday commemorates the story of the Mayflower passengers that founded Plymouth Colony as well as the cultural part of the United States known as the North, or “the Union.” Thanksgiving has since been adopted by the rest of the regions of the United States. Finally, it also the story of an early attempt at racial brotherhood and reconciliation, for the Plymouth Pilgrims’ feast also included local Indians.
One account of the Mayflower passengers and their tiny colony is William Bradford’s (1590–1657) handwritten manuscript called Of Plymouth Plantation, completed in 1651. The manuscript itself disappeared for a time, likely sent to London during the American Revolution by the last Royalist Governor of Massachusetts, Thomas Hutchinson (1711–1780). It was returned just prior to the Civil War.
It is always illuminating to read a direct source. Of Plymouth Plantation is a story of the beginnings of a new people, not unlike The Book of Exodus in the Bible. There is a difference, however. In Exodus, there is an undercurrent of sharp hatred on the part of the Hebrews towards the Egyptians and Canaanites that doesn’t exist in Bradford’s narrative. Of Plymouth Plantation is written in a calm, matter-of-fact style and the narrative is in chronological order.
William Bradford explains the flight of the Separatists from England to Holland, as well as his ideas on the validity of his Separatist, Protestant religious views. In Holland, the Pilgrims were able to worship in freedom, but were forced to work very hard. Eventually, someone in the congregation came up with the idea of migrating to “the northern parts of Virginia.” Key to this was that the Twelve Years’ Truce was coming to an end, and the Spanish were expected to invade Holland. The Pilgrims felt that the Spanish would likely be every bit as cruel as the Indians in the New World. The Congregation thus made plans to migrate. John Carver (c. 1584–1621) was a key organizer, becoming Governor of the colony. He died, probably of a stroke, while doing spring planting in 1621.
The Pilgrims were undersupplied and debt-ridden, although many of the adults were past their physical peak. They had problems with suppliers, and one of their hired ships sprang a leak and had to turn back to England. After a harrowing passage that involved a terrible storm and the emergency use of a great iron screw to shore up a cracked beam mid-voyage, they arrived at Cape Cod. After exploring the area, they turned towards their original destination near what is now New York City, but they were nearly shipwrecked on a stretch of dangerous sea now called Pollock Rip Shoals. The Pilgrims turned back and set up their settlement in Plymouth.
The rest of the story is well known. Their first winter was a disaster; many died. The living could hardly bury the dead. The deaths that first winter would have taken a very emotional toll on the Mayflower passengers. Bradford’s wife Dorothy slipped into the sea and drowned, possibly a suicide. The Mayflower then returned to England with none of the expected furs or lumber to pay off their creditors. The Pilgrims loaded the ship with rocks as ballast.
It is clear that Bradford also kept abreast of political events in England. He writes favorably about the Parliamentary faction winning in the English Civil War of the 1640s. He also writes clearly about the theological controversies affecting Christendom during the seventeenth century.
Another aspect of the narrative is about how one carries out a difficult project with difficult personalities. This is perhaps the most educational part of Bradford’s book. The Pilgrims compromised with creditors, such as selling a firkin of butter to meet some payments. They were able to tolerate the sailors and non-Separatist colonists on the long voyage. When they needed to create a set of rules to take the edge off the factions developing on the Mayflower, they did so by writing the Mayflower Compact. They also picked an excellent military leader in Captain Standish. They didn’t pick Captain John Smith of Jamestown, as he could have taken over and thwarted the Pilgrims’ aims. They were also able to navigate the touchy situation with the Indians by fighting when they needed to fight, but also entering into an advantageous treaty with the Wampanoag.
The Gold on Plymouth Was the Pilgrims Themselves
One would think that the Spanish conquests laid the foundation for most of the dynamic societies in the New World. The Conquistadores conquered the two largest Indian empires and captured their vast stores of gold. Then the Spaniards made their Indians slaves and sent them to mine even more gold, silver, and other minerals for them. The Spanish likewise got the best real estate in the West Indies and created profitable plantations. Apart from South America’s Southern Cone, however, much of Spanish-American society has fallen behind.
What allowed the Pilgrims on Cape Cod’s poor soil to eventually pull far ahead was that in 1621, the treasure on Plymouth Colony was not its resources, but its people.
In retrospect, it is clear that the Pilgrims and their later Puritan kinsmen who followed with Governor Winthrop had a cultural package that was a wealth unto itself. Their dynamism can be found between the lines of Bradford’s story. The Pilgrims had already gone from familiar rural England, with its low, common lanes and green fields, to industrial Holland, where they adapted well enough. From industrial Holland they then traveled to the American wilderness and adapted to it. Then, the Pilgrims’ descendants conquered the entire continent of North America.
Their ability to adapt by absorbing new ideas was part of their cultural gold. For example, the helpful Indian Squanto didn’t teach the Pilgrims how to farm; they had already been farming in England. Instead, Squanto taught them how to farm in the new environment. Specifically, he instructed them in how to fertilize Plymouth’s sandy soil with fish and use non-English crops: corn, beans, and squash. The Pilgrims didn’t reject Squanto’s ideas; they were flexible enough to embrace them. But it wasn’t simply their adaptation to the humble garden they found themselves in. They were also able to adapt to carrying out diplomacy. The Pilgrims’ Indian policy was a masterstroke of Realpolitik, carried out by English yeomen and very minor gentry rather than aristocratic government officials.
Today, New England remains an economic powerhouse of ordered prosperity. When the New Englanders moved west into the interior of North America, the Yankees turned mudflats into great cities and empty plains into wheat fields. Mayflower descendants have even explored space — astronaut Alan Shepard was descended from Mayflower passenger Richard Warren.
From a Darwinian perspective, the Pilgrims have also been wildly successful. Only 51 passengers of the Mayflower had children, and yet today, estimates of the number of Mayflower descendants are upwards of 30 million. To put this in perspective, the population of England in 1621 was approximately 4.6 million; today, it is 54 million.
The Pilgrims also didn’t recognize it, but because they came in family units and settled in a less than optimal area, they were able to create the closest thing to a white ethnostate that North America has yet seen. The Pilgrims were content to do their own labor, and even the humblest of jobs. There was slavery in the New England colonies, but it never really took hold in a culture where doing work was seen as obedience to God — i.e., the Protestant work ethic. When the Yankees started to take slaves as a policy, the purpose was rather to get rid of non-whites. In King Philip’s War, Major John Talcott (1630–1688) of Connecticut implemented a policy of selling captured Indians as slaves to Jamaica. In the process, he paid for the war and made New England whiter.
Celebrating Thanksgiving as an Ethno-Political Act
In nearly every documentary that one can watch on TV about the Pilgrims, the Mayflower story is shown as emblematic of all immigrants. As with all things, however, the story tends to only work for European immigrants. As the black Muslim Malcolm X famously said in a statement of profound truth, “We didn’t land on Plymouth Rock; the rock was landed on us.” To many non-whites in America, the attempt at racial reconciliation at the first Thanksgiving in 1621 is irrelevant when the end result of the English settlement in New England was an overwhelming white victory in King Philip’s War in 1676.
Jewish literature regarding Thanksgiving is mixed. Most articles about the holiday are neutral, and contain recipes and cultural fusion, but as white consciousness rises, Thanksgiving will come increasing under attack. The critical ethnic division in America is between those of New England Yankee descent, their assimilated European cousins, and Jews. Indeed, there is a long history of Jewish attacks on the culture in which they reside. Egyptologist Jan Assmann calls this normative inversion. Essentially, Jews profane whatever is held sacred by others. This strategy is mentioned in Leviticus 26:30:
And I will destroy your high places, and cut down your images, and cast your carcasses upon the carcasses of your idols, and my soul shall abhor you.
Indeed, Leviticus 26:30 can easily be interpreted to mean destroy their high places, and cut down their images, and cast their carcasses upon the carcasses of their idols, and my soul shall abhor them. This casting down of images, and rendering what is sacred profane in regards to Thanksgiving, is already underway.
One example of this in Hollywood is the movie Addams Family Values. In this 1993 film, Wednesday Addams (Christina Ricci) leads a group of clearly identifiable Jews and other minorities to roast and burn blonde-haired WASPs during a play about the Thanksgiving story at an upstate New York summer camp.
But the biggest attacks come from American Indian activists, and these activists are encouraged to do so by Jewish activists. On his website, the late Howard Zinn (Jewish) promotes Indian anti-Thanksgiving attitudes, including a politically correct speech from Wampanoag Wamsutta (Frank B.) James:
I speak to you as a Man — a Wampanoag Man. . . . It is with mixed emotions that I stand here to share my thoughts. . . . The Pilgrims had hardly explored the shores of Cape Cod four days before they had robbed the graves of my ancestors, and stolen their corn, wheat, and beans. . . . Our spirit refuses to die. Yesterday we walked the woodland paths and sandy trails. Today we must walk the macadam highways and roads. We are uniting. We’re standing not in our wigwams but in your concrete tent. We stand tall and proud and before too many moons pass we’ll right the wrongs we have allowed to happen to us.
The speech was written after the Plymouth, Massachusetts authorities invited Wamsutta to speak at a Thanksgiving celebration. According to Zinn and the Wampanoag activist, the speech was “suppressed” after its contents were discovered.
Today, there is a considerable movement among American Indians and their anti-white allies calling Thanksgiving a Day of Mourning. This has picked up steam since Wamsutta’s “suppressed” speech in 1970. Alli Joseph, who has Shinnecock Indian heritage, writes, “. . . for American Indians, Thanksgiving is a reminder of the genocide of millions of our people, the quashing of our culture and traditions and the stealing of our virgin lands.”
In the future, eating Thanksgiving turkey will be a racially-charged, political act. Happy Thanksgiving!
* * *
Like all journals of dissident ideas, Counter-Currents depends on the support of readers like you. Help us compete with the censors of the Left and the violent accelerationists of the Right with a donation today. (The easiest way to help is with an e-check donation. All you need is your checkbook.)
For other ways to donate, click here.
The Counter-Currents 2022 Fundraiser
In Your Heart, You Know Ye’s Right
Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 507 The Best Month Ever on The Writers’ Bloc with Anthony Bavaria
The White Liberal Question: A Nietzschean Response to Jason Köhne
J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Fall of Númenor
Notes from a Tryptophan Coma
How to Survive Thanksgiving
An Old-Fashioned Thanksgiving