- Counter-Currents - https://counter-currents.com -

Fundraiser Update & this Weekend’s Livestream
Charles Murray & the Specter of White Nationalism

[1]950 words 

One of our readers has asked my opinion of Charles Murray’s new book Facing Reality: Two Truths about Race in America (New York: Encounter Books, 2021). I breezed through the ebook version of Facing Reality in just a few hours. I think that this book’s publication is an encouraging sign, and I hope that it will be widely read. America has long denied fundamental truths about race, but in the past year, the costs of these lies have become unbearable. In the words of Jef Costello, we need to “Speak the Truth or Kiss it All Goodbye [2].” Many new minds have been opened to our message by BLM and Critical Race Theory, so Murray’s book has appeared at an opportune moment.

The first truth Murray writes about is that different races in America have different average IQs, which means that they will perform differently in life even in the absence of racial discrimination. This is a very clear and compelling summary of the best science on the issue. This uncomfortable truth means that blaming the unhappy plight of blacks in America (overrepresented among the poor and ignorant, underrepresented among the prosperous and educated) on white racism is not the best explanation, since these patterns persist even in the absence of anti-black discrimination. Indeed, it persists despite pro-black discrimination. It also implies that we will only achieve racial “equity” by discriminating against other races for the benefit of blacks.

The second truth Murray writes about is that different races in America commit crimes at different rates. This is again a useful summary of the latest data. The reason why blacks, especially black men, have so many run-ins with the police is that they commit a disproportionate amount of crime. It has nothing to do with police “racism.” Indeed, if the police are “racist” at all, it is by under-policing blacks and over-policing whites. (See my article “Black Lies Matter [3]” and Richard Houck’s “Law Enforcement and the Hostile Elite [4].”) Black Lives Matter’s sole purpose and effect is to make it safer for blacks to commit crimes, which has predictably led to an explosion of black crime. (See my article “Do Black Lives Matter? [5]“)

For more thorough discussions of Facing Reality, see the reviews by Jared Taylor (“Two Cheers for Charles Murray [6]“) and F. Roger Devlin (“Charles Murray’s Facing Reality [7]“).

I want to focus on a feature of Murray’s argument also mentioned by Taylor and Devlin. Murray warns the current establishment that if they don’t stop promoting non-white identity politics that they are courting a terrible disaster: the rise of white identity politics. Murray instead hopes that America can embrace a color-blind liberal individualism recommended by the Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr. in that speech. It’s all so tiresome.

I am sure that Murray is being sincere. But he really couldn’t say anything else if he wanted his book to be published by a mainstream press and reviewed in the mainstream media. The entire cultural and political establishment in America is united in holding that “racism” and identity politics are terrible things — but only when they benefit white people. This spurious moral dogma is what separates us from the rest of the political spectrum. A morally outrageous double standard is the only thing holding back the floodwaters of white identity politics. But the waters continue to rise, as multiculturalism and open borders continue to ravage white societies.

I don’t know if Joe Sobran coined the phrase “courtier journalist,” but I first learned it from him. A courtier is someone who advises or amuses the powerful. Courtier journalists do this with their pens. It is not necessarily ignoble. For decades, I have been reading Patrick Buchanan columns where he cites historical precedents in order to warn the powerful about the consequences of their follies. He speaks as a member of the establishment to fellow members of the establishment. He assumes a common commitment to preserving the system, then argues that his proposals are the only way to do that.

Murray is one of a host of conservative or neoconservative “courtier scholars” who in recent years have argued against identity politics and for race-blind individualism by raising the specter of white identity politics [8]. For instance, see my reviews of Mark Lilla’s The Once and Future Liberal [9], William Galston’s Antipluralism [10], and Francis Fukuyama’s Identity (here [11], here [12], and here [13]).

It is flattering, I suppose, to be the stalking horse behind which neocons seek to dial American politics back to their preferred policies. As long as we aren’t loved, it is at least nice to be feared.

But the neocon gambit isn’t going to work, for two main reasons. First, the Left isn’t trying to preserve “the system.” They are trying to destroy it. Some of them hate the system even more than they love themselves. Thus they would be content to destroy it even if they suffer. Second, asking non-whites to dial back their identity politics is basically asking them to replace a winning strategy with a losing one. Nobody in his right mind would do that, no matter how nicely conservatives ask, no matter how piously they intone those lines from the Declaration and the “I Have a Dream” speech. Thus, self-respecting whites will be driven to white identity politics out of sheer self-preservation. (For more on this, see part 1 of my essay “White Identity Politics: Inevitable, Necessary, Moral [14].”)

Yes, it is tiresome to be invoked as a boogeyman. But in the long run, people like Murry, Lilla, Galston, and Fukuyama are doing us a favor. Their color-blind civic nationalism isn’t going to save white America. And as more whites realize this, white identity politics will seem far less scary than being treated like a conquered people in their former homelands. Thanks for the free advertising, Charles.

1. This Weekend’s Livestream

On Sunday, June 27th, at noon PST, 3 pm EST, 8 pm UK time, & 9 pm CET, Greg Johnson will be joined by fellow Counter-Currents Brain Trust members Millennial Woes and Frodi Midjord to talk about current events and YOUR QUESTIONS, on DLive [15] and Odysee [16].

Send your questions, comments, and donations through Entropy: entropystream.live/countercurrents [17]

2. Our Fundraiser

Counter-Currents is trying to raise $200,000 this year to sustain and improve our work. Since last week’s update, we have received 18 donations totaling $4,709.41 for a total of 472 donations and a grand total of $65,750.61 since we started our fundraiser on March 10th. That means we are over 30% of the way to our goal. We are deeply grateful to everyone who has helped out. Full information on how to donate appears below.

3. Our Latest Incentive to Give: Our Paywall

Counter-Currents extends special privileges to those who donate $120 or more per year.

First, donor comments will appear immediately instead of waiting in a moderation queue. (People who abuse this privilege will lose it.)

Second, donors will have immediate access to all Counter-Currents posts. Non-donors will find that one post a day, five posts a week will be behind a “paywall” and will be available to the general public after 30 days.

Naturally, we do not grant permission to other websites to repost paywall content before 30 days have passed.

What will go behind the paywall? The short answer is: stuff you really want to see, including:

We generally won’t put things behind the paywall that deal with current events. Instead, we will focus on evergreen material that won’t seem irrelevant after 30 days.

How do you access these privileges?

To subscribe to the paywall, we need three things from you:

To register, just fill out this form and we will walk you through the payment process. There are a number of different payment options.

If you are in the United States, the easiest way to pay for your paywall subscription is by e-check. It is as secure, fast, and convenient as a credit card. All you need is your checkbook:

GreenPay™ by Green Payment

Subscription Level

Note: To register, you need to do more than just send an echeck payment. You need to fill out the form as well, or we won’t know what to do with the echeck payment.

4. How to Send Money to Counter-Currents

Counter-Currents, like all advocates of dissident ideas, depends upon the generosity of readers like you to survive and thrive. If you are a past donor, welcome back. If you are contemplating making your first donation, do it in thanks to the past donors that made it possible for you to find Counter-Currents, and pay it forward so others can experience the same delight in discovery.

There are several ways to help out.

(1) E-Checks

If you are in the United States, E-checks are the fastest and most convenient way to send money to Counter-Currents. All you need is your checkbook.

(2) Credit Cards

Currently the only way we can take credit card donations is through Entropy, a site that takes donations and comments for livestreams. Visit our Entropy page [17] and select “send paid chat.” Entropy allows you to donate any amount from $3 and up. All comments will be read and discussed in the next episode of Counter-Currents Radio, which airs every weekend.

(3) Bank Transfers

It is also possible to support Counter-Currents with bank transfers. Please contact us at [email protected] [19].

(4) Gift Cards

Gift cards are a useful way to make donations. Gift cards are available with all the major credit cards as well as from major retailers. You can either send gift cards as donations (either electronically or through the mail), or you can use them to make donations. Simply buy a prepaid credit card and click here [20] to use it. If you can find a place that sells gift cards for cash, they are as anonymous as sending cash and much safer.

(5) Cash, Checks and Money Orders

Sometimes the old ways are best. The least “de-platformable” way to send donations to Counter-Currents is to put a check or money order in the mail. Simply print and complete the Word [21] or PDF [22] donation form and mail it to:

Counter-Currents Publishing, Ltd.
P.O. Box 22638
San Francisco, CA 94122
USA
[email protected]

Thank you, Boomers, for keeping your checkbooks, envelopes, and stamps. There are youngsters reading this site who have never written a check or put a letter in the mail.

(6) Bill Payment Services

If you wish to make monthly donations by mail, see if your bank has a bill payment service. Then all you need to do is set up a monthly check to be dispatched by mail to our PO box. This check can be made out to Counter-Currents or to Greg Johnson. After the initial bother of setting it up, you never have to think about it again.

(7) Crypto-Currencies

In addition to old-fashioned paper donations, those new-fangled crypto-currencies are a good way to circumvent censorious credit card corporations.

(8) The Counter-Currents Foundation

Note: Donations to Counter-Currents Publishing are not tax deductible. We do, however, have a 501c3 tax-exempt educational corporation called The Counter-Currents Foundation. If you want to make a tax-deductible gift, please email me at [email protected] [25]. You can send donations by mail to:

The Counter-Currents Foundation
P.O. Box 22638
San Francisco, CA 94122
USA

(9) Remember Us in Your Will

Finally, we would like to broach a very delicate topic: your will. If you are planning your estate, please think about how you can continue helping the cause even after you are gone. The essay Majority Estate Planning [26]” contains many helpful suggestions.

Remember: those who fight for a better world live in it today.

Thank you again for your loyal readership and generous support.

Greg Johnson