Print this post Print this post

Nazi Barbie is Sooo Fierce!
Camille Paglia vs. Taylor Swift

Camille Paglia: To use her own words, she "thinks like a man and writes obnoxious books."

Camille Paglia, who says she “thinks like a man and writes obnoxious books.”

1,860 words

Every time you turn around, someone’s hanging another Hakenkreuz on our Tay Tay. Latest and most famous culprit is Camille Paglia, that shooting star of the 1990s critical firmament. On Thursday this acerbic counter-feminist had a piece in the Hollywood Reporter in which she denounced Taylor Swift as a “Nazi Barbie” for swanning around with equally gorgeous female celebs. Almost immediately the story was picked up by The New Republic and New York magazine, as well as the NY Post, the Daily Mail, US magazine, and lord knows where else.

Right now the story has started its second lap, with The Daily Beast critiquing the public response to Paglia.

Now, wherefore this belief-beggaring ferocity, right before Taylor’s big birthday weekend? Paglia sort of explains it in a sidenote:

“Writing about Taylor Swift is a horrific ordeal for me because her twinkly persona is such a scary flashback to the fascist blondes who ruled the social scene during my youth,” she says.

Horrific ordeal! To which the only suitable response is, “Aww! Po’ widdle Camille!”

The essay itself is a short, throwaway deal. New York magazine describes it as “a Camille Paglia essay that reads like a parody of a Camille Paglia essay.”

Girl Squad, Taylor 5th from left.

Girl Squad, Taylor 5th from left.

It’s not really much of an attack on Taylor; its real target is the “girl squad,” that media-contrived phenomenon whereby we are served up endless images and stories about gorgeous models and actresses and singers who like to hang out together. Paglia singles out the Swift name apparently because that’s the moniker that will bring in the most eyeballs:

In our wide-open modern era of independent careers, girl squads can help women advance if they avoid presenting a silly, regressive public image — as in the tittering, tongues-out mugging of Swift’s bear-hugging posse. Swift herself should retire that obnoxious Nazi Barbie routine of wheeling out friends and celebrities as performance props . . .

(The Daily Mail notes, helpfully: “Taylor Swift has no affiliation with the Nazi party . . .”)

Paglia’s priggish hatchet job is basically nothing more than trolling par excellence. It’s done to get headlines, provoke feedback and controversy, and maybe refurbish the Paglia brand. That marque was once stratospherically successful, like some $3500 Italian handbag everyone wanted 25 years ago . . . but which now is—let us say—a bit too loud and out-of-style.


“A humorless, lapel-grabbing fanatic”

Sexual_Personae_(Camille_Paglia_book)_coverIf you haven’t thought much about Camille Paglia lately, here’s a refresher. Once upon a time she wrote this big book (Sexual Personae, 1990) that read like, and began as, a PhD dissertion formulated under the tutelage of Harold Bloom. Somehow the big book got a little attention, and in early 1991 got Camille a New York magazine cover story (written by onetime Yale fashion-plate and Bloom student, Francesca Stanfill). For the next few years, Paglia was lit-crit’s most visible talking head.

She had a good run and gave good value. Whatever subject you threw at her, Camille Paglia would field it with a tart, quotable sound-bite. Her critical insights weren’t so much original as outrageous; but she did have a very good line in contrarian poses and Chestertonian paradoxes.

The fact that her slim, chiseled figura was that of a 40ish lipstick-lesbian dreamboat didn’t hurt any, either—not back in those days (pre-Ellen, pre-Jane Lynch) when most public sapphists appeared to be ugly Jewesses or failed men.

A quick study and smart cookie, Paglia figured out the neat trick of buttering her bread on all sides. She won the hearts of men by saying things males couldn’t say, such as that women didn’t appreciate them enough and that most feminists were off their rockers. She particularly loved Oscar Wilde and the whole gay-male sensibility; anything, in fact, that was outré and transgressive.

She endeared herself to women by declaring herself a failed lesbian—she’d tried to be lez but didn’t really make the cut. Lesbians didn’t like her, she’d say, because of her contrary views. Conveniently enough this is what many lesbians like to think about themselves. And Paglia made purring sounds in favor of classical education, Christianity, family values.

In the words of Groucho Marx—”I think that covers everyone!”

Her first book got a cool reception when it came out in mid-1990. Reviewing it in the New York Times, Terry Teachout wrote, “[T]here is nothing intentionally funny about ‘Sexual Personae,’ which is all too clearly the work of a humorless, lapel-grabbing fanatic with a universal theory to hawk.” But the author’s eccentric bombast brought her attention, and she knew how to deploy it.

Her most famous, least credible pose was her gushing endorsement of the entertainer Madonna Ciccone as a great artist and thinker. This was the critical equivalent of George H. W. Bush’s vaunted addiction to fried pork rinds, and just as unforgettable. It defined Paglia’s public persona for years to come.

One of her first mainstream essays, just before she hit the Big Time, was a New York Times Op-Ed piece called “Madonna—Finally a Real Feminist” (December 14, 1990), wherein she praised Madonna’s risqué music video, “Justify My Love”:

The video is pornographic. It’s decadent. And it’s fabulous . . . “Justify My Love” is truly avant-garde, at a time when that word has lost its meaning in the flabby art world. It represents a sophisticated European sexuality of a kind we have not seen since the great foreign films of the 1950’s and 1960’s.

That over-the-top bonbon has all the earmarks of her style: it’s got porno (S/M actually—a Paglia fave), it’s got Low Art compared to High Art, it’s got elitism (“avant-garde”), it’s got that cultural cringe toward Europe (where they do sex better, because they’re grown-up about it).

tay3Speaking of High vs. Low, you don’t have to think too hard to figure out why Paglia liked Madonna then and now doesn’t like Taylor Swift. There’s that ethnic thing, and the fact that Madonna used the same kind of provocative style as Paglia (yawp-jawed sexual talk, sacrilegious treatment of Christian icons and paraphernalia) to build her celebrity.

And then of course they are near-contemporaries—well, just a decade apart. Madonna arose in the ’80s and peaked in the ’90s. Camille was hot in the ’90s and faded in the oughts. They both imagine themselves to be still at cruising altitude, although their careers began their descent a long time ago, and the bulk of their audiences are the same old Boomers they had a quarter-century ago.

Madonna’s current Rebel Heart Tour has reportedly had trouble selling tickets. (The gross audience for her two 2015 shows at New York’s Madison Square Garden was 28,371[1]; Taylor Swift’s single show at Giants Stadium in the Meadowlands had 110,105.[2])

Meanwhile, Camille Paglia keeps thrusting and feinting at being outrageous, but people aren’t that interested. At one point, a year or two ago, she was claiming to be a “transgender being,” which seems a rather odd play for fresh ink—I mean considering you’re already Camille Paglia! If you look hard, you will see that she was using that “umbrella” T-term correctly—strictly speaking, it could include anybody—but this looked like grandstanding, because in popular understanding transgender has come to mean transsexual. Anyhow, when this didn’t excite the mobs, Paglia tacked the other way and told people how she hated “transgenderism” and how it was a symptom of Western “cultural collapse.” Alas, a hundred other people were already saying the same thing on this tiresome subject, so chalk up another colossal fail for our Camille.

If Paglia wants to get back in the spotlight, I suggest a far more honorable path. Why not bring out the second volume of Sexual Personae, which she assured us had already written when she published volume one 25 years ago?

Which brings us back to our Taylor . . . 

Young Taylor Swift turns 26 today. (Go tweet her Happy Birthday @taylorswift13). Clean, wholesome, the Strength of America. Born in rural Pennsylvania and raised on a Christmas tree farm—seriously!

No cone-shaped bras or other Mediterranean slut-gear for our Tay; she does like to bare her midriff (good abs from those classes at the ModelFIT studio) but never-ever does she show her navel. A very odd entry indeed in the female pop-star tourney.

Her family moves to Nashville when she’s 14 to help enable her singing/songwriting career. (I don’t know about you, but my family wouldn’t cross the street to help my career, and I doubt Paglia’s was much nicer.) The Pennsylvania girl was quickly embraced as a teenage country star, and treated as the embodiment of healthy Southern values. Nice old Presbyterian ladies in Buckhead, sorority girls at SMU, UDC chapters in Richmond and Spartanburg—they all found out who Taylor was in jig time, and bought her records, followed her love life, learned the names of her cats. People of all ages who would never be fans of Lady Gaga or Madonna—let alone Amy Winehouse or Miley Cyrus—knew they could be Swifties and still be clean and decent folks.

tay1 (1)That whole storyline must be so alien and off-putting to Camille Paglia—second-generation Italian from Upstate New York, fan of the Marquis de Sade, lesbian-in-recovery (or denial)—I imagine her in a state of steam-from-ears seething every time she sees a picture of Taylor Swift.

And there’s yet another aspect to Paglia’s animosity most people don’t want to get near, but of course I will. I’m talking about the whole issue of lesbianism, and how it has long been used as a default setting for women who doubt they can fully compete in the social arena.

Let’s say you’re 13, you’re a little tubby or odd-looking or bookish, and/or you’re not interested in clothes and makeup, and you can’t or won’t join up with the Popular Girls your age because all they want to talk about is makeup and booys . . . Well, you have several alternatives to choose from while keeping your self-respect (e.g., be a girl-jock; be a gymnast; be a ballerina if it’s not too late).

But the easiest, most obvious path is to become a tomboyish proto-lesbian. That’s the opt-out choice in the social and mating games.

I don’t know how many women will honestly identify with this story, but in my observation it’s a fairly common pattern. (And forget the coverall excuse of inborn sexual orientation; female sex drive is very plastic in adolescence, and girls have girl-crushes all the time without turning out gay.) From what Camille Paglia tells us, this is pretty much the road she took. And being self-aware, she tells us again and again it was possibly not the right road for her.

tay2But the essential point here is that it still galls Paglia that there were pretty, Popular Girls in her pubescence, and somehow she was not one of them. “Fascist blondes” she now calls them, still rationalizing the choices she made in her youth by claiming the Popular Girls who hung out together were shallow, unambitious conformists. (Those grapes were sour anyway.) That’s what she sees when she looks at the Girl Squads, and the Squaddiest of the girls is Taylor.


1. Wikipedia: Rebel Heart Tour.

2. Wikipedia: The 1989 World Tour.



This entry was posted in North American New Right and tagged , , , , , , , , . Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  1. Jasper Been
    Posted December 13, 2015 at 9:04 am | Permalink

    Camille Paglia will always be a national treasure.

  2. Posted December 13, 2015 at 12:26 pm | Permalink

    I think the real reason Paglia faded from discourse is because she stopped writing. She hasn’t published any major works since “Sexual Personae.” In fact, she has only published six books in the last 25 years, two of which are collections of essays and transcriptions of interviews from when she was a media celebrity (making for two relatively lightweight and rather dated books), two of which (including her last) are photobooks with accompanying text, an anthology of other people’s poetry, and an essay on Hitchcock’s “The Birds.” Not a really significant book in the bunch. This suggests that Paglia was a one-hit wonder, and either doesn’t have anything else important to say or is too distracted by other matters to write. As for the second volume of SP, I’d say that after 25 years of its non-appearance that it has likely gone the way of the third volume of the Dangerous Visions anthology series, which Harlan Ellison has insisted that he’s been working on for the past 43 years in spite of the fact that most of the authors included in it have since shuffled off this mortal coil.

  3. anonymous
    Posted December 13, 2015 at 2:24 pm | Permalink

    Actually, subjectively from my experiences, they were shallow unambitious conformists, but this comment is not sour grapes, I was a beautiful redhead who at that young age saw through the B.S. Love you, Camille.

  4. Petronius
    Posted December 13, 2015 at 3:40 pm | Permalink

    Well, MM has some (and some painfully obvious) points here, and the “Nazi barbie” and “fascist blondes” remarks were really unworthy and cheap attention seekers.

    But “Sexual Personae” remains a terrific, one-of-a-kind book, and Camille generally kicks major ass for me. Her contradictions are a feature and not a bug, as far as I’m concerned. That’s how she taught me to understand and appreciate both Dionysos and Apollo. Let’s also not forget that she rather “covered everyone” by alienating and pissing everybody, left or right, off in one way or another, at some given point or another, rather than be Everybody’s Darling, far from it!

    “Break, Blow, Burn” is also great, and taught me a lot about reading poetry.

  5. Posted December 13, 2015 at 9:47 pm | Permalink

    Taylor Swift is from Western Pennsylvania. Fly-over country. An alleged cultural wasteland. As for myself, I love driving through the region and seeing the big old Whiteguys, thick-necked and broad-shouldered, tooling down the backroads in their Harley’s. If understated power is the essence of male glamour, those rednecks have it. Kids recruited from small-town Pennsylvania are always over-represented in the NCAA National Wrestling Championships. They are tough and coachable. Hard life in the countryside turns them into the winning combination of bad-ass and sincere goy recruit. The regional pool of uncorrupted but scrappy White kids is why Cael Sanderson chose to coach at Penn State which is otherwise as suspect as Taylor Swift: Too pleasant. Too White.

    As for Camille Paglia, I learned lots from her. But as a Judeophile, she couldn’t go further with the second volume of Sexual Persona which was to take the reader through 20th Century Art. Paglia just couldn’t turn the Culture of Critique on her beloved mentors who were often the force behind Modern Art, Post-Modern Art and blah, blah, blah. Paglia was stymied. She quit. What we’re getting is the smell of her stasis.

    Nice articles, by the way, on Taylor Swift. I had no idea.

    • Posted December 17, 2015 at 7:54 pm | Permalink

      Thanks for the kind words, but one little correction! Taylor Swift is from eastern Pennsylvania,—as indeed is Margot Metroland (exurban Reading vs exurban Philadelphia). Still the sticks, though. Horse farms, trap-shooting clubs, Christmas tree farms. “Mad Anthony Wayne drank ale in this inn.” That sort of thing, you bet! (Not a cultural wasteland, and neither is the western part of the state, which a ‘Metroland’ ancestor helped settle in the 1780s.)

      But your basic point about Taylor is well taken. There is something about her that is honest and down-home about her that resounds with many of us, and that is the secret to her fan base.

  6. rhondda
    Posted December 14, 2015 at 6:01 pm | Permalink

    This is very good Margot. At first I thought you were just dissing Paglia, but when I looked up Taylor Swift, I realized she writes her own songs and she writes about feelings. This is what has been missing in pop music for a while : that attraction is not just physical and that there are emotions that go with it and women have been so put down for having feelings by the likes of Paglia. When Madonna became a name, and really Paglia helped, I thought that if she denegrates the Virgin Mary, then there is only one direction to go and indeed she took it. I am not a Catholic and indeed in Protestantism, the Virgin Mary is denigrated in a subtle way by being ignored and really regarded just as a prop. I think it has confused so many women who know they cannot be the Virgin Mary, but being a whore is in the cards thanks to Paglia and the likes of Madonna who are telling girls this is what men want. ( need I mention Miley Cyrus). To paraphrase Freud: What do men want anyway?
    It is quite telling that she was jealous of the popular girls at school and so she had to be a contraian to make her name. Yet a lesbian? That just makes me laugh and think she is an intellectual coward. eg can’t live what she preaches. She does make men feel good about themselves though, so I guess that was her mission in life. She does seem to have repressed anything feminine about herself, so she must diss that in anyone else. I am glad you wrote in support of Taylor Swift. What is wrong with having girlfriends who are your peers anyway? Is that also what Paglia has missed out on?

  7. sean
    Posted December 16, 2015 at 2:48 pm | Permalink

    Taylor is a beautiful blonde. There are beautiful continental Europeans. I hate the pitting of one European ethnic group against another.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.
Comments are moderated. If you don't see your comment, please be patient. If approved, it will appear here soon. Do not post your comment a second time.
Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Our Titles

    White Identity Politics

    The World in Flames

    The White Nationalist Manifesto

    From Plato to Postmodernism

    The Gizmo

    Return of the Son of Trevor Lynch's CENSORED Guide to the Movies

    Toward a New Nationalism

    The Smut Book

    The Alternative Right

    My Nationalist Pony

    Dark Right: Batman Viewed From the Right

    The Philatelist

    Novel Folklore

    Confessions of an Anti-Feminist

    East and West

    Though We Be Dead, Yet Our Day Will Come

    White Like You

    The Homo and the Negro, Second Edition

    Numinous Machines

    Venus and Her Thugs


    North American New Right, vol. 2

    You Asked For It

    More Artists of the Right

    Extremists: Studies in Metapolitics


    The Importance of James Bond

    In Defense of Prejudice

    Confessions of a Reluctant Hater (2nd ed.)

    The Hypocrisies of Heaven

    Waking Up from the American Dream

    Green Nazis in Space!

    Truth, Justice, and a Nice White Country

    Heidegger in Chicago

    The End of an Era

    Sexual Utopia in Power

    What is a Rune? & Other Essays

    Son of Trevor Lynch's White Nationalist Guide to the Movies

    The Lightning & the Sun

    The Eldritch Evola

    Western Civilization Bites Back

    New Right vs. Old Right

    Lost Violent Souls

    Journey Late at Night: Poems and Translations

    The Non-Hindu Indians & Indian Unity

    Baader Meinhof ceramic pistol, Charles Kraaft 2013

    Jonathan Bowden as Dirty Harry

    The Lost Philosopher, Second Expanded Edition

    Trevor Lynch's A White Nationalist Guide to the Movies

    And Time Rolls On

    The Homo & the Negro

    Artists of the Right

    North American New Right, Vol. 1

    Some Thoughts on Hitler

    Tikkun Olam and Other Poems

    Under the Nihil

    Summoning the Gods

    Hold Back This Day

    The Columbine Pilgrim

    Confessions of a Reluctant Hater

    Taking Our Own Side

    Toward the White Republic

    Distributed Titles


    The Node

    The New Austerities

    Morning Crafts

    The Passing of a Profit & Other Forgotten Stories

    Gold in the Furnace