Counter-Currents
Counter-Currents Radio Podcast No. 33
The Trial of Socrates:
Aristophanes’ Clouds, Part 1
Greg Johnson
/
RSS Feed
Seated Socrates, fresco from ancient Ephesus
54:53 / 472 words
[jwplayer file=”http://cdn.counter-currents.com/radio/CCR-Johnson_Trial-of-Socrates-Aristophanes-CLOUDS-1-of-3.mp3″ streamer=”rtmp://s3cxt7hxkp9tvh.cloudfront.net/cfx/st” provider=”rtmp” duration=”3293″]
To download the mp3, right-click here and choose “save target as.”
To subscribe to our podcasts, click here.
This is the first of three podcasts on Aristophanes’ Clouds. This lecture opens with a discussion of the Sophist Antiphon.
The first words, which were cut off, were something to the effect of: “Before we examine Aristophanes’ Clouds, we will first deal with the reading from Antiphon in A Presocratics Reader.”
The Source of the Lecture
In September and October of 1998, I gave a course of eight, two-hour lectures on “The Trial of Socrates.” We covered the following topics and texts:
- Myth, pre-philosphical concepts of order, and the presocratic philosophical background of Aristophanes’ Clouds
- Aristophanes’ comedy Clouds, which gives a very unflattering portrayal of Socrates
- Plato’s dialogue Theages, which can be read as a rebuttal to the Clouds
- Plato’s dialogue Euthyphro, which is set just before the trial of Socrates and deals with one of the accusations against him, namely impiety
- Plato’s Apology of Socrates, his speech to the jury at his trial
- Plato’s dialogue Crito, which is set in his prison cell as Socrates awaits execution
- Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, which describes the last conversations and death of Socrates
The whole class was taped, but the tapes of the first lecture, which was an introduction to the whole course, and the last lecture, on the Phaedo, have disappeared. Nevertheless, the six remaining lectures, which I will release in 12 separate parts, contain a lot of useful material.
The books for the class are:
- A Presocratics Reader, ed. Patricia Curd (we used the first edition; the pagination may be different for the second edition)
- Plato and Aristophanes, Four Texts on Socrates: Plato’s “Euthyphro,” “Apology of Socrates,” “Crito,” and Aristophanes’ “Clouds”, ed. and trans. Thomas West and Grace Starry West
- Plato, Theages, in The Roots of Political Philosophy: Ten Forgotten Socratic Dialogues, ed. Thomas L. Pangle
The very last words of this recording are cut off as the tape ran out, but the gist of the sentence is this: “If you say that there are gods everywhere, and that natural substances and forces are gods, and these gods care nothing about human affairs, that is not, strictly speaking, atheism. But from the point of view of the defenders of the various local religions, it is the practical equivalent of atheism, for it undermines piety and belief in the gods of the city.”
If anyone is interested in producing a transcript of this lecture, we will gladly publish it. Ideally, we would like one person to do a draft transcription and then place it online to allow other listeners to offer corrections. Please contact Greg Johnson at mailto://[email protected] before starting work, so we can prevent wasteful duplication of efforts.
Greg Johnson
Editor-in-Chief
3 comments
As usual Great Stuff. Thanks.
Good listening. Wish I had a teacher like you when I took Ancient Phil. Mine was terrible.
The Ancients thought the “old” was good just because it was old? Not, perhaps, that having “stood the test of time”, any proposed alterations to the state of existing affairs should be thoroughly and diligently scrutinized? The latter mindset seems far more plausible to me.
Contrast this with the Young Turk mentality of the Obamaites and their ilk today, which arbitrarily asserts the exact opposite: that the old is bad just because it is old (White, reactionary(???), uncouth), and that some ethereal bright and shiny newness, couched generally under the rubric of “change”, is the way – the only way – to go.
Their change is a world devoid of White heritage, values, and people. I think we’ll pass.
Comments are closed.
If you have Paywall access,
simply login first to see your comment auto-approved.
Note on comments privacy & moderation
Your email is never published nor shared.
Comments are moderated. If you don't see your comment, please be patient. If approved, it will appear here soon. Do not post your comment a second time.